Can't Say They Didn't Know - Communications with local #NewtonMA government & public officials
November 29, 2022
Newton City Clerk's Office
Public Records Request
1000 Commonwealth Avenue, Newton, MA 02459
Attn: Carol Moore, City Clerk
City of Newton Law Department
1000 Commonwealth Avenue, Newton, MA 02459
Attn: Alissa O. Giuliani, City Solicitor
Dear City Clerk Moore and City Solicitor Giuliani:
I will further narrow my request per the City's November 28, 2022 email.
I am including the City Solicitor as addressee since her staff has been advising me as well. And I am not certain which office will address this.
I now seek SOLELY the medical and/or scientific basis utilized and/or cited by the Mayor as her independent determination to invoke the City's employee COVID vaccine mandate and official promotion of the COVID vaccines for Newton residents. And the same as pertains the School Board and Superintendent. And in both cases, the medical and/or scientific basis to continue to do so without reconsideration.
I feel this request remains of the upmost importance to the public. Since the Summer of 2021 I have been providing every City elected official a plethora of documentation supporting that COVID "vaccines" pose health risks which must be balanced against the actual health risks of COVID itself which have been conflated in terms of numbers, causation, severity, and morbidity. For instance, why did reported flu cases go essentially to zero during the reporting of "COVID" cases? Why were deaths "with" COVID conflated to be "from" COVID? Why has the City banned information on ANY vaccine risk? Why has the City banned ALL information on alternative safe and effective therapeutics?
And in terms of the City's overstatement of vaccine efficacy which I have repeatedly pointed out, the ONLY City reply to me after 18 months has been City Council President Albright first sending a Gates Foundation chart comparing the death rate of vaccinated and unvaccinated people in the United States, hardly objective, or even accurate by flawed methodology (the Washington Post recently reported that a majority of COVID deaths in the United States, 58%, were vaccinated). Councilor Albright followed up with a few journal study citations which actually acknowledge vaccine waning efficacy. The mRNA spike protein stays and spreads in the body, contrary to initial assurances (potentially leading to cardiovascular, neurological and other disease risk).
In sum, please process this much narrowed request without fee.
If you still require a fee, please explain the basis.
Thank you.
Sincerely,
Jim Epstein
cc:
Newton Mayor Fuller
Newton City Council
Newton School Committee
Newton School Superintendent
Newton Dept. of Health & Human Services
Dr. Ashish Jha
Newton Medical Advisory Group
Holtzman Medical Group
MA Secretary of HHS
MA Commissioner of Public Health
_________________________
[Nov 28, 2022] Re: record request #22-855:
Mr. Epstein,
A search was ran based on your most recent email dated November 18, 2022, the search was ran as follows:
All internal emails to or from Mayor Ruthanne Fuller and Superintendent David Fleishman’s email accounts with the terms “Covid-19 Vaccine” OR “Covid-19 Booster” between dates January 1, 2020 – November 3, 2022.
After review of your request for public records, to produce the documents in order to comply with the request, the City has determined it will take approximately 86.2 hours, two of which will be waived, at a rate of $25.00 per hour for the lowest paid employee capable of reviewing, compiling, and if necessary, segregating and redacting documents or information as required by law. An itemization of this estimate is set forth below.
There are approximately 5,177 email documents that are potentially responsive to just the above-described search, based on our initial search, this does not include the School Committee’s emails.
The City will need to review all 5,177 documents in order to identify and compile all the documents that are actually responsive to your request, and to segregate and potentially redact any documents that are required to be withheld by law. The City’s review for responsiveness and segregation will be done simultaneously by one City employee at an estimated time of 60 seconds per written document. This leads to an estimated total time of 86.2 hours. After the two-hour deduction, 2 hours at a rate of $25.00 per hour equals a good faith estimate of $2,107.08.
In accordance with M.G.L. c. 66, the City now notifies you that the good faith estimate to produce the documents equals $2,107.08. Once payment of this amount is received, the City will produce the documents responsive to your request in the time allowed.
Alternatively, please let me know if you would like to discuss reasonable modifications that could allow records to be provided more efficiently and affordably.
Newton City Clerk's Office
Public Records Request
_________________________
November 19, 2022
Dear Newton Mayor Fuller, City Council, and School Committee:
I must now conclude that the entirety of the Newton City Government and elected officials remain steadfast in not considering or discussing (1) an end to the City's and Schools' official public promotion of the emergency use mRNA COVID-19 vaccines and boosters -- including for children down to the age of 5 -- and (2) an end to the mandate that City and School employees must get the emergency use mRNA COVID-19 vaccines and/or boosters as a condition of employment.
Moreover, I must now conclude that the entirety of the Newton City Government and elected officials remain steadfast in not considering or discussing any public notice whatsoever of the existence of the health risks of these vaccines as well as the availability of alternative safe and effective therapeutics, to accompany the City's and Schools' widespread official public promotion of the said vaccines and boosters. This is required to allow for informed consent and weighing risks/benefits.
I currently have an FOIA Public Records Request to learn the basis for these refusals. But thus far the City Solicitor and City Clerk refuse to waive the fees beyond a very nominal amount and elect to reject that the entirety of this inquiry is in the public interest.
I respectfully request that at least any one or more of you advise the City Solicitor and City Clerk that the entirety of my inquiry, set forth immediately below in my 11/18/22 memo, should be deemed in the public interest for the purposes of fee waiver, that is, rather than for my personal or commercial benefit or interest.
Thank you.
Sincerely,
Jim Epstein
cc:
Newton School Superintendent
Newton City Solicitor Giuliani
Newton City Clerk Carol Moore
Newton Dept. of Health & Human Services
Dr. Ashish Jha
Newton Medical Advisory Group
Holtzman Medical Group
MA Secretary of HHS
MA Commissioner of Public Health
_________________________
November 18, 2022
Re: Public Records Request #22-855
City of Newton Public Records
City of Newton Law Department
Alissa O. Giuliani, City Solicitor
Greta McConnell
Newton City Clerk's Office
Carol Moore, City Clerk
Dear Madams/Sirs:
After receiving the City's last message, I'll go ahead and narrow and modify my public interest records request, including for fee waiver (not limited two hours).
With this in mind, please provide the documents and public records used in considering, and forming the basis and justification for, the official city and school decisions of the Mayor, School Committee and School Superintendent:
1. Publicly to promote, urge or recommend that Newton residents get the COVID-19 vaccine(s) and booster(s) for the duration these decisions have remained in effect.
2. Publicly to promote, urge or recommend that Newton residents down to the age of 5 years get the COVID-19 vaccine(s) and booster(s) for the duration these decisions have remained in effect.
3. To require and mandate that City and School employees get the COVID-19 vaccine(s) and/or booster(s) as a condition of their employment for the duration these decisions have remained in effect.
Beyond this, if you have alternative language which you feel could better allow the records to be provided more efficiently under public interest fee waiver, I would more than welcome that for consideration.
Alternatively, if you feel that this request can not qualify as being in the public interest, I respectfully ask for your reasoning.
In any case, an early reply would be most appreciated.
Thank you.
Sincerely,
Jim Epstein
_________________________
November 10, 2022
Dear Each Member of Newton City Council including Councilor Kelley,
I just heard back from City Councilor Kelley either clarifying or implying that her point was not that this matter should not be docketed. Rather, that she is not the particular City Councilor to docket this.Hence, I reiterate that this request is being made to each and every City Councilor, and I ask City Councilor Kelley which City Councilor(s) she feels would be appropriate or agree to docket this.Jim Epstein110 Manchester RoadNewton Highlands, MA 02461cc:Newton Mayor FullerNewton School Committee and SuperintendentNewton Medical Advisory Group Dr. Ashish Jha Newton City Solicitor GiulianiNewton Dept. of Health & Human ServicesNewton City Clerk Carol Moore _________________________
November 10, 2022
Dear City Councilor Kelley,
Thanks for getting back. You predicate you refusal to docket upon your "faith" in the CDC and your doctor. Rather than faith, I am asking that you -- and each City Councilor -- accommodate this request to docket hopefully upon the exercise of knowledge, reason, and judgment. I have provided you, and each City Councilor, with more than a plethora of studies, reports and facts showing vaccine significant health risks and failures in preventing contracting and transmitting COVID-19. This information is also readily available from uncensored online and other media sources. And City Council President has stated in writing her recognition that "These are the kinds of conversations we need to have."But beyond that, since the City and the Mayor are still actively, officially and widely publicly promoting, as well as mandating for employees, these vaccines, the informed consent of Newton residents requires that they be presented with this information, including the availability of safe therapeutics, so each can exercise their own balancing. This is so, whether or not you personally happen to share my views, which is no defense to what is your moral and legal responsibility.I hereby strongly renew my request to you, and by copy to each and every City Councilor, that this obviously (or what clearly should be) important matter be docketed by November 14, 2022, or otherwise in time for the November 21, 2022 City Council Meeting.
Jim Epstein
cc:All Members of Newton City Council including President Albright Newton Mayor FullerNewton School Committee and Superintendent Newton Medical Advisory Group Dr. Ashish JhaNewton City Solicitor GiulianiNewton Dept. of Health & Human ServicesNewton City Clerk Carol Moore
November 9, 2022
From: Andrea W. Kelley
Jim, I'm not the person to accommodate your request, as I am one of those that puts faith in what the CDC and my primary care doctor have advised. I have been vaccinated, boosted and have had Covid-19. Likely another Councilor who shares your view is more likely to docket this.
_________________________
November 9, 2022
Dear Each Member of the Newton City Council,
In view of the quickly approaching November 14, 2022 deadline without response from City Council President Albright, I hereby request that ANY Newton City Council Member have docketed for the upcoming November 21, 2022 City Council Meeting, consideration of the below matter as a recommendation by City Council to be made to the Mayor (as well as to the Mayor in her capacity as Member of the School Committee). The Mayor or City of Newton take the following steps:1. With all public written statements emanating from City Officials or Departments announcing, discussing or recommending the COVID-19 vaccine or booster, there should also be posted something at least along the lines as follows:(a) There may be certain health risks in taking the vaccine or booster for certain groups of the population which may outweigh the health risks of not taking the vaccine or booster.(b) There are available safe therapeutics which may be effective against catching or in ameliorating the effects of Covid-19.2. Since being vaccinated does not prevent an individual from contracting or transmitting COVID-19, all mandates that City and School employees receive the COVID-19 vaccines or boosters are lifted as a condition of their employment.To be clear, I am not citing any particular wording for the above, but that the thrust of what I say is carried forward. That, of course, is consistent with City Council President's previous stated recognition that "These are the kinds of conversations we need to have."
Whoever elects to take up this matter, please keep me posted on the docketing of this item. Or if you feel that you don't have the authority to do this or that this matter does not merit requisite importance or relevancy for City Council, please reply ASAP with that information.
Jim Epstein
cc: Newton Mayor FullerNewton City Council President AlbrightNewton School Committee and SuperintendentNewton Medical Advisory GroupDr. Ashish JhaNewton City Solicitor GiulianiNewton Dept. of Health & Human ServicesNewton City Clerk Carol Moore _________________________
November 8, 2022
Dear City Council President Albright,
While I do appreciate your stated recognition that "these are the kinds of conversations WE NEED TO HAVE," I'm wondering that your current silence is your REFUSAL to engage City Council in these conversations.
I repeat my request that you have docketed the matter of my November 4, 2022 email to you (below) by the November 14, 2022 deadline, apprising me of this.
If you feel that you don't have the authority to do this, or you feel this matter is unimportant, please reply ASAP with that information.
Sincerely,Jim Epstein
cc: Newton Mayor FullerNewton City CouncilNewton School Committee and SuperintendentNewton Medical Advisory GroupDr. Ashish JhaNewton City Solicitor GiulianiNewton Dept. of Health & Human ServicesNewton City Clerk Carol Moore _________________________
November 4, 2022
Dear City Council President Albright,
Albeit my Covid-19/Vaccine FOIA request is currently being processed by the City of Newton, I see no reason why the City should refrain from immediately pursuing (in fact I feel there are negative consequences in not doing so) the following steps:1. With all public written statements emanating from City Officials or Departments announcing, discussing or recommending the COVID-19 vaccine or booster, there should also be posted something at least along the lines as follows:(a) There may be certain health risks in taking the vaccine or booster for certain groups of the population which may outweigh the health risks of not taking the vaccine or booster.(b) There are available safe therapeutics which may be effective against catching or in ameliorating the effects of Covid-19.2. Since being vaccinated does not prevent an individual from contracting or transmitting COVID-19, all mandates that City and School employees receive the COVID-19 vaccines or boosters are lifted as a condition of their employment.I hereby request that you have docketed for the upcoming November 21, 2022 City Council Meeting consideration of the above matter as a recommendation by City Council to be made to both the Mayor and the School Committee. Inasmuch as the current docket deadline is November 14, 2022 for that meeting, I request that you initiate this as quickly as possible.To be clear, I am not citing any particular wording for the above, but that the thrust of what I say is carried forward. That, of course, is consistent with your stated recognition that "These are the kinds of conversations we need to have."
Please keep me posted on the docketing of this item.Sincerely,Jim Epstein110 Manchester RoadNewton Highlands, MA 02461cc:Newton Mayor FullerNewton City CouncilNewton School Committee and SuperintendentNewton Medical Advisory GroupDr. Ashish JhaNewton City Solicitor GiulianiNewton Dept. of Health & Human ServicesNewton City Clerk Carol Moore
_________________________
November 3, 2022
Dear City Solicitor Giuliani,Thank you. I've submitted the public records request to the online link. By copy, I'm also providing email notice of this to Carol Moore, City Clerk, Newton Records Officer. This is per the City webpage which you also linked since Clerk Moore's assistance may be needed as this public records request entails several different City Offices and Departments.
Sincerely, Jim Epstein
cc: Newton City Clerk Carol Moore
November 3, 2022
Mr. Epstein: You may submit a public records request by clicking on the following link: Make request - NextRequest - Modern FOIA & Public Records Request Software. That link can also be found on the following City webpage which summarizes the process for submitting a records request as well as contact information for the City’s Records Access Officer: https://www.newtonma.gov/government/city-clerk/public-records-requests#:~:text=You%20may%20request%20the%20documents,assist%20in%20obtaining%20the%20documents.
Alissa Ocasio Giuliani
City Solicitor, City of Newton Law Department
1000 Commonwealth Avenue, Newton, MA 02459
617-796-1240
_________________________
November 2, 2022
Dear City Council President Albright,
Thank you for getting back. I hope you are speaking for City Council when you say "These are the kinds of conversations we need to have" (albeit it has taken 15 months to get here). While you say your studies show that vaccines have prevented severe disease and have saved lives, I feel that you should be aware that in many cases, death and severe illness WITH Covid-19 has been counted as death and severe illness FROM Covid-19. Moreover, substantial financial incentive, at least in the United States, has existed for hospitals to label the cause as Covid-19. And even the studies you cite acknowledge vaccine waning efficacy going forward with ever changing variants. In fact, increased disease risk is now being associated with a condition known as Vaccine Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome (VAIDS) by virtue of the spike protein which remains throughout the body, contrary to initial claims. In that connection, you elect to omit any risk-benefit analysis that while, yes, in some elderly or infirmed cases, the vaccines may have been called for, but this is not the case for the wider population, especially going forward and especially for those of school age where Covid-19 health risk is infinitesimally small. Moreover, you elect to omit that flu statistics went practically to zero during the period everything was counted as Covid-19.Which brings me to the crucial point behind my repeated communications. That is, since the City continues actively to promote and recommend -- even mandating for employees which should immediately cease -- the injections of experimental mRNA vaccines, there must be simultaneous presentation of the issues surrounding vaccine health risks for there to be informed consent. And the City must lift its ban against reporting on available alternative safe and effective therapeutics. It is disingenuous for the City to claim concern for its residents in the absence of that.I look forward to continuing our "conversations" and to the City's compliance with my FOIA request.
Sincerely, Jim Epstein
cc: Newton City Solicitor GiulianiNewton Mayor FullerNewton City Council Newton School Committee and Superintendent Newton Medical Advisory Group
November 2, 2022
From: Susan Albright
Mr. EpsteinThe Scientific peer-reviewed journals are full of data on the efficacy of the Covid-19 vaccine. Here are just a few from the New England Journal of Medicine, the CCD, the IDP journal, and the Lancet. There are many many scientific articles on this point. The data indicates the efficacy of the vaccine in prevention of severe disease. I certainly have not "refused" to address your issues. These are the kinds of conversations we need to have. The vaccine has saved lives. https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa2117128#:~:text=Estimates%20of%20vaccine%20effectiveness%20in,to%2093.1)%20at%207%20months.https://covid.cdc.gov/covid-data-tracker/#vaccine-effectivenesshttps://idpjournal.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s40249-021-00915-3https://www.thelancet.com/journals/laninf/article/PIIS1473-3099(22)00320-6/fulltext
November 2, 2022
Alissa Ocasio Giuliani, Esq.Newton City SolicitorCity Hall, 1000 Commonwealth Ave.Newton Centre, MA 02459
Dear Newton City Solicitor Giuliani,
The City of Newton Government persists in continuation and implementation of its COVID-19 policies, recommendations, programs, mandates and expenditures despite ample information countering the safety and efficacy of the vaccines and related City mandates and recommendations.In follow up of the below thread of email/letters (identified as 10/18/22, 10/18/22, 10/18/22, 10/19/22, 10/20/22, 10/25/22, 10/28/22, 10/31/22), the undersigned will intend to make a Freedom of Information Act Request (FOIA) in accordance with the Massachusetts Public Records Law.(Actually my request will be a follow up of 15 months of inquiry on my part replete with studies and documentation for the City of Newton to address cautioning on vaccine health risks and dubious efficacy. The SOLE City response thus far is a biased Gates Foundation chart from City Council President Albright purporting to show a death rate graph by vaccination status based on utterly incomplete and inaccurate methodology -- which President Albright now refuses even to address. That's all!)In order to direct the FOIA to the appropriate officials, please provide me with the name, official title and email address of the City of Newton's current Records Access Officer(s) (RAO) for, or covering, the City of Newton's Executive and Mayor's Office and Departments, Newton City Council, Newton Police Department, Newton Fire Department, and Newton Public Schools, as they would relate to providing information and documentation leading to the City of Newton's COVID-19 and vaccine determinations and implementations, including any revisions, running through the current date.Finally, I would expect to receive an exemption from fees for this request as it is clearly in the public interest rather than for my personal or commercial benefit or interest. If you feel that, legally, this is not the case, please advise with explanation.Please reply by email to jamesepstein5@aol.com. Thank you.
Sincerely, Jim Epstein
cc: Newton Mayor FullerNewton City Council and President Newton School Committee and SuperintendentNewton Medical Advisory Group
October 31, 2022
Newton Public School Superintendent Kathleen Smith Newton School Committee Chair Tamika OlszewskiNewton School Committee Members
Dear Superintendent Smith, Chair Olszewski and Newton School Committee,
Earlier today, the Newton Public Schools published and distributed its NPS District News entitled "Vaccine Edition" where the School Department doubles-down on recommending the COVID-19 mRNA vaccine and booster. And it does so, no less, specifically for school age children who have infinitesimally small COVID health risk. The School Department's linked State discussion touts the complete safety and effectiveness of the mRNA shots without one word or any information whatsoever to consider the issue or potential of their health risks (and increasingly questionable efficacy).The Superintendent and School Committee share full responsibility for this decision for the same reasons set forth in my below letter to the Mayor.That not one member of the School Committee or one member of its Medical Advisory Group, will even address this question, at least from a moral standpoint, is not only disconcerting, it is shocking.
Sincerely, Jim Epstein
cc: City Solicitor Giuliani Mayor Fuller City Council President AlbrightCity CouncilNewton Dept. of Health & Human ServicesNewton Medical Advisory Group Members Dr. Ashish Jha
October 28, 2022
Dear Mayor Fuller,
In your city-wide Mayor's Update of today, Friday October 28, 2022, you persist in promoting the COVID-19 mRNA vaccine and booster (down to the age of 5) WITHOUT ONE WORD about consideration of, or weighing or balancing, the issue of the ever increasing data on health risks -- NOT ONE WORD! You remain culpable for withholding such information from Newton residents who adhere to Newton official health recommendations denying them informed consent. Your culpability is not excused or mitigated by your link to state announcements that the vaccines/boosters are "safe and effective". This is the case because of the legal doctrine of "scienter". You KNOW about the issue of health risks. Moreover, intentional misconduct vitiates your City immunity from responsibility as well as for those officials making similar determinations to withhold information on the known issue of health risks.For the record, this repeats the numerous requests for you to make that information known on all occasions where you publicly promote the COVID-19 mRNA vaccines and/or boosters.Aside from the legal implications, your utter lack of any feeling of moral duty is disconcerting to say the least.Sincerely,Jim Epstein110 Manchester Rd.Newton Highlands, MA 02461 cc:City Solicitor GiulianiCity Council President AlbrightCity CouncilSchool Committee Chair OlszewskiSchool CommitteeSchool Superintendent SmithNewton Dept. of Health & Human ServicesDr. Ashish Jha
October 25, 2022
Newton Mayor Ruthanne Fuller, Newton City Council President Susan Albright, Newton City Solicitor Alissa Ocasio GiulianiCity Hall, 1000 Commonwealth Ave.Newton Centre, MA 02459
Newton Public School Committee Chair Tamika Olszewski, Newton Public School Interim Superintendent Kathleen Smith Newton Education Center 100 Walnut StreetNewton, MA 02460
Dear Mayor Fuller,
City Council President Albright, City Solicitor Giuliani, School Committee Chair Olszewski and School Superintendent Smith:
As you may be aware, yesterday (Oct. 24) the New York State Supreme Court reinstated all New York City employees who were fired for not receiving a COVID-19 vaccine, ordering back pay and saying that their rights had been violated. Importantly, the court found that "being vaccinated does not prevent an individual from contracting or transmitting COVID-19." The court is saying point blank that the City does not have a right to mandate and hold somebody's job hostage if they don't take an experimental shot.Albeit the case was not in Massachusetts, this is now a landmark ruling to be used around the country in other cases. It's only a matter of time that the City of Newton would be engaged in litigation were it not voluntarily to follow the directives of New York's case, which you are requested to do. As a first step, you are requested immediately to remove from all City, including Police and Fire Departments, and all School Department, publications, both in print and electronic, the requirement as a condition of employment that all employees be fully vaccinated against COVID-19, or have an approved medical or religious exemption on file with the Human Resources Department.Finally, with regard to liability for future determined medical harms incurred by vaccine coerced employees, while there may or may not arise government immunity to the extent employees receive workman's compensation or disability benefits, that does not extend to the misconduct of City officials coupling that coercion with the active concealment of the vaccine's then known health risks as extensively documented to you by the undersigned.
Sincerely ,Jim Epstein
cc: City CouncilSchool Committee Dr. Ashish Jha _________________________
October 20, 2022
Dear Newton City Solicitor Giuliani,
In view of today's events, I need to supplement my email letter to you of yesterday.As you may be aware, despite overwhelming public opposition, the CDC advisory committee earlier today voted to add COVID-19 mRNA shots to the "immunization schedules" for children and adults in the United States. As you also may be aware, once a vaccine is part of the childhood schedule, its manufacturers are shielded from injury lawsuits under the National Childhood Vaccine Injury Act (NCVIA) -- which appears to be the cynical motivation behind the CDC vote. That is, to shield the manufacturers from liability precisely as the truth is more and more coming out about these injections.Coincidentally, also today the Mayor in her public Update renewed promotion of the COVID-19 vaccine as a safe and healthy course for all residents, and as an obligation to keep the community healthy. This, in the face of her and City Council having been presented more than repeatedly with increasingly overwhelming evidence of the mRNA injection's long term serious health risks due to its spike protein now known to remain in the human body creating immunodeficiency for disease and infection as well as increased cardiovascular and neurological risks -- on which to this day the Mayor and the City of Newton remain utterly silent! .This is relevant because City officials would not be protected by NCVIA's manufacturers' liability immunity.So I would ask that you confirm the legal basis of this as well for the Mayor and City Council President, again, in the hopes that the City might be more proactive in determining to reserve its federal COVID funds for potential future claims.
Sincerely, Jim Epstein
cc: Mayor FullerCity Council President AlbrightCity CouncilSchool CommitteeDr. Ashish Jha _________________________
October 19, 2022
Alissa Ocasio Giuliani, Esq.Newton City SolicitorCity Hall, 1000 Commonwealth Ave.Newton Centre, MA 02459
Dear Ms. Giuliani,
Per the below email thread I have requested that Mayor Fuller and City Council President Albright facilitate the City of Newton to reserve its federal COVID funds for potential claims by coerced City and School employees having received the mandated COVID injections as a condition of employment, who at a future date may be determined hurt by the injections in terms of their health.While it might be nice to know that City officials would feel a moral obligation to do this, I am writing to you because I feel this entails a legal obligation to the extent that immunity from individual liability under the Public Readiness and Emergency Preparedness Act (PREP Act) does not apply in cases of willful misconduct, i.e., coercion and failure to disclose vitiates informed consent.In any event, for the benefit of any such disproportionately harmed City and School employees, I am asking that you confirm for the Mayor and City Council President this potential liability. My thinking is that knowing this, the City might be more proactive in determining to reserve its federal COVID funds.
Thank you.Sincerely, Jim Epstein
cc: Mayor FullerCity Council President AlbrightCity CouncilSchool CommitteeDr. Ashish Jha
October 18, 2022
Dear Newton City Council President Susan Albright,Thank you for getting back with the chart from a source largely funded by the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, so historically heavily committed to promoting the mRna vaccinations, it can hardly be considered objective (or accurate by incomplete methodology). That deficient sourcing is especially relevant now that even Pfizer admits the lack of ANY evidence that the mRna injections stopped transmission (which admission your reply fails to address). Moreover, I can submit a growing number of extensive studies precisely reporting negative efficacy with reduced immune response going forward, e.g., https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35780805/ , https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4224504
In any case, my October 18 email requests reservation of the City's federal COVID funds for the potential FUTURE harmful health effects determined to be caused by the injections. As I previously wrote to you, "with every released study, there is confirmation that I was correct in my series of emails placing you on notice that they do, in fact, harm the human body."
If you are prepared to summarily dismiss this potentiality, I would certainly like to hear back from you on that. Otherwise, I feel it is incumbent on you to submit to the Mayor and City Council my prudent proposal for the City to reserve those funds for coerced City and School employees having received the mandated injections as a condition of employment, who at a future date are determined hurt by the injections in terms of their health. Sincerely,
Jim Epstein
Committee to Hold Local Officials Accountable
(CHLOA)
Newton, MA
cc:
Mayor Fuller
City Council
School Committee
Dr. Ashish Jha
October 18, 2022
From: Susan Albright
Dear Mr. Epstein
Please review the chart on this webpage, showing the death rate of unvaccinated people as compared to vaccinated people in the United States.
October 18, 2022
Dear Mayor Fuller,
Your October 17, 2022 Financial Future Update to Newton Residents states that a portion of federal COVID funds received by the City will be providing for a "forthcoming economic stability and mobility program to those hurt disproportionately by the pandemic."
Now that Pfizer admits that there was NEVER ANY EVIDENCE that the mRna injections stopped transmission, I'm requesting that the City reserve those funds for coerced City and School employees having received the mandated injections as a condition of employment, who at a future date are determined hurt by the injections in terms of their health.
At the least, this would seem a very prudent measure.
Sincerely,
Jim Epstein
Committee to Hold Local Officials Accountable
(CHLOA)
Newton, MA
cc:
City Council
School Committee
Dr. Ashish Jha
Feb 11, 2022
Subject: Committee to Hold Local Officials Accountable (CHLOA)
Dear Mayor Fuller:
The collapse of your Covid narrative is now complete -- borne out by your capitulation today on Newton's mask mandate.
You do so, however, upon false and dishonest predicate. You claim in your February 11, 2022 Mayor's Update that your extensively promoted high Newton vaccine rate made this possible. To put it mildly, BS! (You know it, I know it, we all know it.)
But more than your false narrative of vaccine efficacy, your continued vaccine promotion in the face of the skyrocketing documentation of serious vaccine harm, is unconscionable.
See, for example, 1,000 "Peer Reviewed Medical Papers Submitted To Various Medical Journals, Evidencing A Multitude Of Adverse Events In Covid-19 Vaccine Recipients" --
Or note, for example, that the Pentagon's ("about as reliable as it gets") Defense Medical Epidemiology Database (DMED) is overflowing with evidence showing a massive uptick in serious illnesses due to Covid-19 injections --
https://pandemic.news/2022-02-09-pentagon-dmed-data-proves-disease-military-covid-vaccines.html
And specifically as pertains young adults and children, there is a very long list of peer reviewed research, "Covid-19 Vaccination Adverse Events that Could Harm Children References"
https://www.rwmalonemd.com/references
As you may be aware, only certain limited vaccine batches are associated with a high percentage of the deaths, disabilities and illnesses. The reason for this is addressed in the video linked at the bottom of this thread.
Vaccinated Newton residents need to be able to avail themselves of this critical information. Therefore, you absolutely must provide all Newton families and residents with the following links:
"How Bad is My Batch. Batch codes and associated deaths, disabilities and illnesses for Covid 19 Vaccines"
https://www.howbadismybatch.com
The collapse of the Covid narrative does not undo the harms and crimes against humanity already committed by certain Government officials and their officially cooperating partners and physicians in Newton. This organization has pledged to seek full criminal accountability. This says nothing of what likely will be unprecedented civil liability by claimants and classes of claimants.
Sincerely,
Jim Epstein
Committee to Hold Local Officials Accountable (CHLOA)
cc: Newton City Council, School Committee & Health Officials; Newton Official Participating Physicians; MA Commissioner of Public Health & Secretary of HHS
bcc: citizen mailing lists
Jan 28, 2022
Subject: Committee to Hold Local Officials Accountable (CHLOA)
Dear Mayor Fuller:
I note that, finally, after almost two years of your COVID-19 update reporting, you do admit (in your Jan. 27, 2022 Mayor's Update): "[Only] approximately 40% of the [Newton-Wellesley Hospital] patients hospitalized with COVID-19 are hospitalized primarily for COVID-19. The majority were admitted primarily for another illness and then also found to have COVID-19."Therefore your previous numbers have been deceptively inflated by 2-1/2 times. But that is only part of the deception. In a 78 page document titled CDC 2019-Novel Coronavirus (2019-nCoV) Real-Time RT-PCR Diagnostic Panel – For Emergency Use Only – Instructions for Use, published in July 2021, the CDC clearly stated that the PCR test was not capable of distinguishing between any of the numerous Coronaviruses … i.e. the common cold, influenza A & B and/or SARS-cov-1 or SARS-cov-2 (COVID-19).
Since Massachusetts PCR tests are being run up to cyclic threshold (CT) of 45 cycles, whereas only CT less than 20 cycles is considered infectious and contagious, about 90% are essentially false positives. So your 40% is more like 4% of what you have been reporting for nearly two years as causative COVID-19 cases.In your next Mayor's Update, I feel that it is incumbent upon you to at least explain, if not apologize for, this deception to Newton residents.
Sincerely, Jim Epstein Committee to Hold Local Officials Accountable (CHLOA)
cc: Newton City Council, School Committee & Health Officials; Newton Official Participating Physicians; MA Commissioner of Public Health & Secretary of HHS
bcc: citizen mailing lists
Jan 26, 2022
Subject: Committee to Hold Local Officials Accountable (CHLOA)
Friends, I want to take this opportunity to emphasize that Newton Mayor Fuller's individual culpability runs deep, very deep -- both as Mayor and Ex Officio member of the Newton School Committee. The case against her is well established. Mayor Fuller has acted with full scienter. AS EARLY AS SEPTEMBER 17, 2021, I wrote to her, followed up by many many documented communications since -- each and every one completely ignored by the Mayor. The September 17, 2021 letter is as accurate and true today, even more so, as subsequent events have confirmed, as the day it was written. Moreover, there is the Mayor's continuing utter silence on therapeutics. At the same time, she doubles down on the vaccines despite their known serious health risks and Omicron having ended the pandemic (or "plandemic").
Here is that letter: * * * * *
September 17, 2021
DUPLICATE VIA CERTIFIED MAIL
RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED
Honorable Ruthanne Fuller
Mayor, City of NewtonNewton City Hall
1000 Commonwealth Ave.Newton Centre, MA 02459
Dear Mayor Fuller:
I note that to date, NOT ONE of your many many many COVID-19 Mayor's Updates has EVER mentioned the availability of proven known safe therapeutics, including Ivermectin and Hydroxychloroquine.
This, despite controversy surrounding the safety, unknowns, deceptive reporting and efficacy of the various vaccines which were approved only for emergency use in the absence of readily available therapeutic treatments. As I previously wrote you, the FDA's "non-emergency approved" Pfizer vaccine is not expected to be available for years. And regardless of questions on the vaccines, why would you withhold vital information on therapeutics if your concern over the health of Newton residents were paramount?
For your information, the largest state in India, Uttar Pradesh, recently promoted Ivermectin and Hydroxychloroquine to its massive population of an estimated 241 million people and "has now become free from COVID-19 government officials informed on Friday. The recovery rate has increased up to 98.7% proving the effectiveness of Ivermectin as part of the Uttar Pradesh Covid Control Model.” https://www.hindustantimes.com/cities/lucknow-news/33-districts-in-uttar-pradesh-are-now-covid-free-state-govt-101631267966925.html
Your singular promotion of vaccines persists despite the United States currently admitting and dispersing throughout the country this year alone over one million untested and unvaccinated illegal immigrants -- with a full scale invasion of ten thousand yesterday alone pouring in at ONE 'borderless' crossing.
https://populist.press/shocking-video-10000-illegals-just-invaded-texas-town-overnight/
https://cis.org/Bensman/New-Beachhead-Opens-Biden-Border-Crisis
This certainly belies any seriousness and credibility in claiming that vaccines, or even testing, are earnestly needed as an essential tool or mandate for handling COVID-19.
Moreover, last year's dramatic reduction of flu cases to practically zero indicates COVID-19 cases merely numerically replaced the flu. The current PCR testing is unable to distinguish COVID-19 from the flu, which precisely is the reason the CDC is withdrawing the use of such test after December 2021. (I guess until then the COVID-19 'cases' will remain high and then drastically reduce which can be 'claimed' due to the vaccines.)
And, as everyone now knows, COVID-19 deaths have been inflated by counting all those dying WITH COVID-19 as dying FROM COVID-19 irrespective of other serious medical condition(s) likely to have caused the fatality. Furthermore, there is now official data from the UK that 8 times as many people have died due to the Covid Vaccines in 6 months than people who have died of COVID-19 in 18 months.https://theexpose.uk/2021/09/16/8-times-as-many-died-due-to-covid-vaccines-than-people-who-died-of-covid-19/
In any event, I urge that your very next COVID-19 Mayor's Update fully inform on the availability of therapeutics. Also, I feel it is incumbent upon you to present the differing reports and opinions on the safety and efficacy of the vaccines to enable informed consent as to their use. Even the CDC just this month quietly downgraded the definition of "vaccine" from "produce immunity to a specific disease" to "produce protection from a specific disease". Beyond that, many maintain an experimental mRNA agent is not even a "vaccine".
You have a duty to do more than just cite CDC or NIH and be done with it. Their ever evolving statements and findings may or not be accurate. This is especially the case since there are reports that NIH's Dr. Fauci faces criminal indictment for falsifications and blocking therapeutic information, to occur once the stolen November 3 Presidential election is rectified.
Sincerely,
Jim Epstein
cc:
Newton City Council, Attn: Susan Albright, President
Newton School Committee, Attn: Ruth Goldman, Chair
Newton Health and Human Services Department, Attn: Deborah Youngblood, Commissioner [End of letter]* * * * *
Jim Epstein, Committee to Hold Local Officials Accountable (CHLOA)
cc: Mayor Fuller, Newton City Council, School Committee & Health Officials; Newton Official Participating Physicians; MA Commissioner of Public Health & Secretary of HHS
bcc: citizen mailing lists
Jan 21, 2022
Subject: Committee to Hold Local Officials Accountable (CHLOA)
Dear Mayor Fuller:
Your January 20, 2022 Mayor's Update (received since my below email) features Newton Medical Advisory Committee Spokesman, Dr. Ashish Jha's admission essentially that Omicron has ended the pandemic. Nevertheless, you and Dr. Jha (1) conflate the Covid hospital numbers by citing "with Covid" rather than "from Covid", (2) claim, without any support beyond a misleading anecdote by Dr Jha, the "booster is just terrific", and (3) double down on pushing 'vaccines' for children despite Omicron ending the pandemic.I suggest you and Dr. Jha take a look at Scottish data reported in this week's "Public Health Scotland COVID-19 & Winter Statistical Report (18 December 2021 to 14 January 2022)" showing "that the COVID-19 age standardized case rate is highest among the two-dose vaccinated and lowest among unvaccinated. It further shows this trend of negative efficacy for the double-vaccinated persisting for hospitalizations and death."
This data is consistent with what is increasingly being shown from other nations. A day later, your January 21, 2022 Mayor's Update, with still more pushing of 'vaccines' on children, self congratulates for your part in securing mandatory full "vaccination and compliance" in order to keep their jobs, by 790 of Newton's 884 permanent municipal employees, the remainder either not yet having received all three doses or they successfully secured religious or medical exemptions.A remarkable achievement indeed, coercion under the threat of losing your job, benefits and pension.Your persistence at this late date with a dangerous false narrative is doing you no service.
Moreover, your simultaneous touting of what is your success essentially in withholding vital medical information (vaccine health risks, available therapeutics etc.) voids consent for the injections. Likewise, your threatening with the loss of livelihood many hundreds, is coercion which voids consent to the injections. In either case, a colossal crime against humanity. As I said downthread, "the days of accountability lie ahead."
Sincerely, Jim Epstein Committee to Hold Local Officials Accountable (CHLOA)
cc: Newton City Council, School Committee & Health Officials; Newton Official Participating Physicians; MA Commissioner of Public Health & Secretary of HHSbcc: citizen mailing lists
Jan 20, 2022
Subject: Committee to Hold Local Officials Accountable (CHLOA)
Dear Mayor Fuller and Newton School Committee:
Both City of Newton and Newton Public Schools' Official Web Pages extensively cite the CDC as the source for much of their published information. The CDC has now admitted that natural immunity is superior to vaccinated immunity alone at preventing Covid hospitalizations and deaths. https://beckernews.com/bombshell-cdc-admits-natural-immunity-superior-to-vaccinated-immunity-alone-at-preventing-covid-hospitalizations-deaths-43799
Moreover, the latest Public Health Data published in the UK proves that Covid 19 Vaccines increase the risk of infection, hospitalization and death due to Covid-19. https://dailyexpose.uk/2022/01/20/public-health-data-confirms-vaccinated-more-likely-to-die-of-covid/
These admissions and findings are consistent with the cautions I conveyed throughout my extensive series of communications to you and all City elected officials from August through December 2021.While the CDC's previous misinformation does not protect you from legal accountability, it remains your ethical responsibility to make immediate rectification going forward.Cease and desist from furthering dangerous vaccine misinformation and make the appropriate corrections in all City and School Web Pages.
Thank you, Jim EpsteinCommittee to Hold Local Officials Accountable (CHLOA)
cc: Newton City Council, Newton Health Officials; Newton Official Participating Physicians; MA Commissioner of Public Health & Secretary of HHSbcc: citizen mailing lists
Jan 16, 2022
Subject: Committee to Hold Local Officials Accountable (CHLOA)
Dear Mayor Fuller:
I note that uncharacteristically your Mayor's Covid-19 Update (Jan 13, 2022) makes no announcement on the availability of Covid 'vaccines' and boosters. This may or may not be in response to the below cease and desist. Still, your Jan 13 Update carries an implication that 'vaccines' and boosters are currently effective. This implication is unfounded, especially on the Omicron variant, which renders the 'vaccines' obsolete. Moreover, the injections have been shown to be counter-productive. https://rumble.com/vsnr6a-omicron-makes-vaccine-mandates-obsolete.htmlConsistent with the cautions I conveyed to you in my exhaustive series of communications, the Triple Vaccinated are developing Acquired Immunodeficiency, now at an alarming rate.https://dailyexpose.uk/2022/01/15/triple-vaccinated-developing-ade/Cease and desist in any way from furthering the false narrative that 'vaccines' and boosters are beneficial. I urge that rather than your taking pride in 'success' in getting a high percentage of Newton residents 'vaccinated', you take steps to insure that no further injections occur locally, and most especially to the numerous children you have already subjected to these life-long health risks.This same admonition applies to all Newton officials and participating physicians. Thank you,Jim EpsteinCommittee to Hold Local Officials Accountable (CHLOA)cc: Newton City Council, School Committee & Health Officials; Newton Official Participating Physicians; MA Commissioner of Public Health & Secretary of HHSbcc: mailing lists_________________________
Sent: Jan 10, 2022
Subject: Local Accountability for Covid and 'Vaccine' Crimes Against Humanity
Dear Newton Mayor Fuller, Newton School Committee, Newton City Council, Newton Health Officials and Newton Official Participating Physicians:1. In follow up of the below email which you were cc'd, please watch this additional linked video:https://kapwi.ng/c/Pq9bGqLJkP
2. As set forth in the above linked video, immediately cease and desist in any way from causing or furthering Covid related injections, constituting criminal and civil offenses against humanity.3. Please be advised that reliance upon actions of the CDC, Governor of Massachusetts and any other authority will not serve as a defense from accountability -- nor is there any informed consent for such injections.4. Please be advised that current plans entail formation of local citizen committee(s) in order to ensure legal process for Covid related offenses and crimes.Sincerely,Jim EpsteinNewton Residentbcc: mailing lists _________________________
Sent: Jan 9, 2022
Subject: Local Accountability
Friends:
The fog Is lifting.
The days of accountability lie ahead.
I believe that Newton Local Government Officials, Leaders and Participating Physicians, not merely those on the National and International level, need to be held accountable.
I have more than established and documented such case.
Now couple that now with this. Watch:
https://odysee.com/@Corona-Investigative-Committee:5/Mike-Session-86-en:0
Jim Epstein
Newton Resident
cc: Newton Mayor, City Council, School Committee & Health Officials; Newton Official Participating Physicians; MA Commissioner of Public Health & Secretary of HHS
November 20, 2021
Subject: Liability for Administering School Vaccine Program
DUPLICATE VIA CERTIFIED MAIL - RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED
Newton School Committee
Newton Public Schools Superintendent
100 Walnut Street
Newton, MA 02460
To All Members of the Newton School Committee and Superintendent:
In your capacity as public employees, or officials, your decisions affect the lives of others.
I previously explained in writing both to the Newton School Medical Advisory Committee and Holtzman Medical Group the specific legal basis for their civil liability. The Medical Advisory Committee is the official source relied on for all Covid actions taken by the Schools. Holtzman Medical administers the Schools' clinical Covid vaccine injection program.
As the School Committee is not comprised of medical professionals, the legal basis is somewhat different.
I have more than exhaustively explained -- carefully documented in writing -- to the Mayor, School Committee, and Superintendent the many health and safety risks and dangers surrounding the Covid-19 vaccines being administered from Public Schools to Newton children.
Yesterday you were notified and given scientific evidence (below).
Therefore, following legal case precedent, going forward you cannot avail yourself of qualified immunity as you are aware of harm or potential harm. Moreover, this means that you may be held personally liable -- be sued -- if our children are harmed from the vaccines. Since the City may not cover you, you would have to hire your own attorney to defend any claims brought against you, and your personal assets would be exposed in such litigation.
As a minimum, at this time please take responsibility for your decisions and immediately suspend the Newton Public Schools clinical Covid-19 vaccine injection program.
Thank you for your attention.
Yours truly,
James E. Epstein
cc:
Newton Mayor Fuller
Mayor Fuller's Director of Communications
Newton Medical Advisory Committee
Newton City Council
Newton Health and Human Services Commissioner
Newton Public Schools Health Services Director
Holtzman Medical Group
Massachusetts Acting and Associate Commissioners of Public Health
Massachusetts Secretary of Health and Human Services
November 19, 2021
To All Members of Newton City Council:
1. Mayor Fuller, in her Thursday, November 18, 2021, City-Wide Email Update, gives, as she states:
"A big thank you to the City's Health and Human Services Department, Public Schools and Holtzman Medical Group for partnering to put vaccine into the arms of 1,503 youngsters at clinics this past weekend and after school Wednesday (and another 109 signed up to be vaccinated Thursday afternoon)."
And, the Mayor (apparently proudly) elects to points out that:
"In the two weeks since vaccines became available for 5 to 11-year-olds, 49% of Newton's 5 to 11-year-olds received a first dose."
2. On the very same day, November 18, 2021, the undersigned received this published report of a scientific study just completed in Sweden which finds that the side effects of the full-length spike-based vaccines (the ones already given to 49% of Newton kids) impairs DNA damage repair and inhibits V(D)J recombination for adaptive immunity.
https://www.mdpi.com/1999-4915/13/10/2056/htm
3. Please stop this madness!
Respectfully,
Jim Epstein
cc:
Newton Mayor Fuller
Mayor Fuller's Director of Communications
Newton Medical Advisory Committee
Newton School Committee
Newton Public Schools Superintendent
Newton Health and Human Services Commissioner
Newton Public Schools Health Services Director
Holtzman Medical Group
Massachusetts Acting and Associate Commissioners of Public Health
Massachusetts Secretary of Health and Human Services
November 17, 2021
Ellen Ishkanian
Director of Communications
Office of the Mayor
City of Newton
Dear Ellen,
Since it appears you may or may not respond by email (I fear the Mayor may be blocking my emails or even sending to trash), would I be able to meet with you on behalf of the Mayor to go over the draft Informed Consent Notice? You can call or text me at the number below my signature block.
I have made some revisions for purpose of clarification, so the proposed Notice for our discussion would be as follows:
"INFORMED CONSENT NOTICE
1. Receiving the Covid-19 vaccination will prevent you from ever again being able to acquire full natural immunity and will prohibit you from donating plasma due to the lack of remaining antibodies. Each additional vaccination or booster will further reduce remaining natural immunity.
2. While unvaccinated people with full natural immunity are generally protected against all mutations and variants of Covid-19, the vaccinated will require repeated boosters since the previous injection or booster will not protect against future mutated variants. The higher the number of persons receiving Covid-19 vaccinations and boosters increases the likelihood and spread of Covid-19 variant mutations.
3. While long term health ramifications from the Covid-19 vaccines are currently unknown, in the shorter term higher rates of certain cardiovascular and neurological disorders have been reported."
Again, feel free to propose further revision, especially if you or the Mayor thinks anything stated is inaccurate or untruthful.
As I said previously, I'm hoping this can occur forthwith since there seems to be a race by the Mayor to get as many kids injected as quickly as possible before safety concerns are more widely known in Newton. From my interactions with others, it appears that Newton may be way behind the rest of the nation in either recognizing or acknowledging these dangers, now being imposed on innocent children.
Sincerely,
Jim Epstein
cc:
Newton Mayor Fuller
Newton Medical Advisory Committee
Newton School Committee
Newton Public Schools Superintendent
Newton City Council
Newton Health and Human Services Commissioner
Newton Public Schools Health Services Director
Holtzman Medical Group
Massachusetts Acting and Associate Commissioners of Public Health
Massachusetts Secretary of Health and Human Services
November 15, 2021
Ellen Ishkanian
Director of Communications
Office of the Mayor, City of Newton
Dear Ellen,
I'm hoping you now had a chance to discuss the Covid 'vaccine' safety concerns with the Mayor, as you said you would.
The chief concern of our group appearing outside the Oak Hill Middle School pediatric injection clinic over the weekend was to inform parents with kids on the safety issues surrounding the vaccines, which as you know, are actually experimental gene therapy.
Our goal was that there be at least informed consent for injecting the kids. Unfortunately, as you know from being there, the Mayor's office deployed police which prevented our meaningful discussion with entering parents and kids.
Therefore, in the absence of any meaningful discourse -- including being prevented for over 3 months now from any discussion whatsoever on vaccine safety with ANY City official -- I am proposing the posting at the injection sites something along the lines of the following:
"INFORMED CONSENT NOTICE
1. Receiving the Covid-19 vaccination will prevent you from ever again being able to acquire full natural immunity and will prohibit you from donating plasma due to the lack of remaining antibodies.
2. While unvaccinated people with full natural immunity are generally protected against all mutations of Covid-19, the vaccinated will require repeated boosters since each injection can cause further mutation.
3. While long term health ramifications from the Covid-19 vaccines are currently unknown, in the shorter term higher rates of certain cardiovascular and neurological disorders have been reported."
I'll cc all the medical doctors on the School's Medical Advisory Committee as well as medical personnel with the injection clinics administrator, Holtzman Medical Group.
I hope they will go over the proposed "informed consent notice" and get back as soon as possible on whether this is acceptable, or they propose revision(s), or find any of it inaccurate or untruthful.
I'd also like to know the Mayor's thinking on something like this.
Since there seems to be a race by the Mayor to get as many kids injected as soon as possible before safety concerns are more widely known in Newton, I'm hoping this can occur forthwith.
Many thanks.
Jim Epstein
cc:
Mayor Fuller
Medical Advisory Committee
School Committee
City Council
Holtzman Medical Group
From: Jim Epstein
To: eishkanian@newtonma.gov
Cc: rfuller@newtonma.gov
Sent: Sat, Nov 13, 2021 6:49 pm
Subject: Fwd: Newton Parents - Ask Mayor Fuller a Few Questions
November 13, 2021
Ellen Ishkanian, Director of Communications, Office of the Mayor City of Newton
Ellen, Please see the below.
I appreciate the opportunity earlier today (Saturday) outside the Oak Hill Middle School pediatric injection clinic to have briefly discussed with you the problem I am having in getting the Mayor to respond (substantively) to ANY of the medical and safety concerns raised surrounding the Covid-19 'vaccines'. If the Mayor (or you for that matter) have been reading my emails (or if saved and you are able to review), there's no need here to go into my thoroughly documented presentations. The difference between the Mayor and myself over the safety, science and effectiveness of the 'vaccines' could not be greater. Nevertheless, my emails have presented more than credible evidence and documentation of the health dangers associated with the 'vaccines'. In view of the criticality of these issues, they deserve not to be summarily dismissed with silence. While I understand a large majority of Newton residents have already taken the shots (to me more than unfortunate), those under 12 years of age have largely not yet done so. I would hope the Mayor, as an ex officio member of the School Committee, agrees that there is absolutely nothing more important to Newton Public School students then their health and safety -- nothing!Importantly, it is not necessary that the Mayor agree with all or most of the findings I have presented, merely that she agree there are risks and unknowns of sufficient level to hold off on vaccinating the children until there is resolution on safety and efficacy, especially compared to the monumentally lesser risk of Covid morbidity and mortality to that young age group.
In that regard, I am so thankful that you will bring this to the Mayor's immediate attention. I believe she has the authority to suspend the injection of kids with what remains, regardless of anything else, an experimental gene therapy.
Sincerely,
Jim Epstein
cc: Mayor Fuller
From: Jim Epstein
To: rfuller@newtonma.gov
Cc: Justin@HoltzmanMedical.org; GTrey@HoltzmanMedical.org; Jeff@HoltzmanMedical.org; Andy@HoltzmanMedical.org; Deb@HoltzmanMedical.org; Avi@HoltzmanMedical.org; lisa@holtzmanmedical.org marylou.sudders@mass.gov; Margret.R.Cooke@MassMail.State.MA.US; Lindsey.Tucker@MassMail.State.MA.US; rfuller@newtonma.gov; ruthanne@ruthannefuller.com; deanofpublichealth@brown.edu; mahrokh_irani@brown.edu; jjhlarson@yahoo.com; sbnelson@mgh.harvard.edu; sbnelson@partners.org; brendaanders@gmail.com; erubin@hsph.harvard.edu; fmalafronte@hsph.harvard.edu; ksadler@mgh.harvard.edu; ksadler@partners.org; oneeka.williams@gmail.com; oneekawilliams@gmail.com; drdeedeedynamo@gmail.com; zalez77@verizon.net; citycouncil@newtonma.gov; salbright@newtonma.gov; jkrintzman@newtonma.gov; dcrossley@newtonma.gov; vdanberg@newtonma.gov; mlaredo@newtonma.gov; rlipof@newtonma.gov; aleary@newtonma.gov; akelley@newtonma.gov; lgentile@newtonma.gov; adowns@newtonma.gov; rwgrossman@newtonma.gov; dkalis@newtonma.gov; msgreenberg@newtonma.gov; enorton@newtonma.gov; cmarkiewicz@newtonma.gov; bnoel@newtonma.gov; lbaker@newtonma.gov; jmalakie@newtonma.gov; bhumphrey@newtonma.gov; hryan@newtonma.gov; abowman@newtonma.gov; pwright@newtonma.gov; joliver@newtonma.gov; tlucas@newtonma.gov; schoolcommittee@newton.k12.ma.us; ruth_goldman@newton.k12.ma.us; goldmanr@newton.k12.ma.us; raycanadab@newton.k12.ma.us; albrightma@newton.k12.ma.us; shena@newton.k12.ma.us; olszewskit@newton.k12.ma.us; prennere@newton.k12.ma.us; shieldsk@newton.k12.ma.us; millermattsc@newton.k12.ma.us; David_Fleishman@newton.k12.ma.us; dyoungblood@newtonma.gov; ruth_hoshino@newton.k12.ma.usSent: Fri, Nov 12, 2021 4:05 pm
Subject: Newton Parents - Ask Mayor Fuller a Few Questions
Parents, Before entering the Newton Public Schools Holtzman Medical Group Pediatric Covid-19 'Vaccine' Clinics, ask Mayor Fuller these questions and watch the below linked video of "Experts"
How do we put the whole puzzle of the Covid vaccine program together to make a story that makes sense?
Why was access to life saving medicines like hydroxychloroquine, ivermectin and others, suppressed?
Why was knowledge about them suppressed?
Why was any doctor who dared speak against the mainstream vaccine narrative de-platformed?
Why were all the side effects from the horrific vaccines being suppressed as well?
Why would you vaccinate children with a nearly 100% chance of recovery from Covid?
Why the hell would you put a needle into them that has side effects of blood clots, myocarditis, increased miscarriages, increased cancer, increased autoimmune diseases, most likely infertility, and then the dreaded antibody dependent enhancement reaction, for a disease from which children have a 99.998 per cent chance of recovery. So you have to ask yourself, what is going on here? ONLY if you think it was actually about your health care or the health care of your children and about what's best for you and your children, do you have all these questions.
Let's reverse engineer the mass Covid vaccine program. Only if you look at things with the right perspective -- the right glasses -- will things make sense and those glasses are not the eyes of a decent person.
Is this the worst crime in human history? Is this a eugenics program that is designed to murder a percentage of us, more immediately, then chronic illnesses, and make infertile the rest?
How else do things make sense?
PLEASE DO NOT HAVE YOUR CHILDREN INJECTED WITH THE COVID VACCINE!
Video of "Experts" https://kapwi.ng/c/kKB7AKtpxJ
RE: NEWTON PUBLIC SCHOOLS PEDIATRIC COVID-19 VACCINE PROGRAM NOTICE TO ALL MEDICAL STAFF MEMBERS OF HOLTZMAN MEDICAL GROUP INCLUDING: Justin Holtzman, MD, MHSA, Internal MedicineGary Trey, MD, MPH, Gastroenterology and Internal Medicine Jeff Lucak, PA-C, Physician Assistant Andy Huynh, PA-C, Physician Assistant Deb Adner, PA-C, Physician Assistant Avi Smith, Director, COVID 19 Response
1. This constitutes notice to the above named individuals, who are all medical doctors or professional medical personnel: Dr. Justin Holtzman, Dr. Gary Trey, Physician Associate Jeff Lucak, Physician Associate Andy Huynh, Physician Associate Deb Adner, and COVID-19 Director Avi Smith.
2. Newton Mayor Fuller recently issued this city wide email "Update":
"Wednesday, Nov. 10, 2021 Mayor's Update
We’re excited to have vaccine clinics for our 5- to 11-year-olds this weekend. The 960 appointment slots filled up in two hours.Can you volunteer this weekend so we can extend the hours?With more volunteers helping to check in children and their caregivers, usher them to the vaccination stations, administer vaccines and help make second appointments, we can extend the hours of the two clinics this Saturday, Nov. 13 and Sunday, Nov. 14 until 5:00 p.m. at Oak Hill Middle School and Newton North High School.Interested? Get more information and sign-up here. We need both clinical and administrative volunteers.We’re also looking for volunteers for afterschool pediatric vaccine clinics which are now in the planning stages.The pediatric COVID-19 vaccine clinics are being organized by our Health and Human Services Department in partnership with the Newton Public Schools. Huge thanks go once again to the Holtzman Medical Group for running the clinics.
Check newtonma.gov/vaccines for more information and to sign up if the clinic hours are extended.Warmly,Ruthanne"
3. As shown above, the Mayor's November 10, 2021 "Update" concludes with, "Huge thanks go once again to the Holtzman Medical Group for running the clinics."
4. The Mayor's above November 10, 2021 "Update" links to the following City of Newton's Health and Human Services announcement: "Youth COVID-19 Vaccine Clinic (Ages 5-11).
Post Date: 11/05/2021 1:21 PM
Holtzman Medical Group, in partnership with the Newton HHS & Newton Public Schools, will hold COVID-19 vaccine clinics open to anyone 5-11 years old. You do not need to live in Newton to attend.
All children must have a consent form completed by a parent or legal guardian and must be accompanied by an adult. Consent forms can be found on the registration page and will be available available on-site.
Saturday, Nov. 13, 9:00 a.m. to 1:00 p.m. and
Sunday, Nov. 14, 9:00 a.m. to 1:00 p.m.
At Newton North High School, 457 Walnut Street, Newton
and at Oak Hill Middle School, 130 Wheeler Road, Newton
Clinics will be held at both locations on both days." https://www.newtonma.gov/Home/Components/News/News/166/189
5. The City of Newton and the Holtzman Medical Group elect to label what is experimental gene therapy as "COVID-19 vaccines".
6. The long-term side effects of this experimental gene therapy a/k/a COVID-19 vaccines are unknown.
7. It is already known that there are disturbing short-term complications from this experimental gene therapy a/k/a COVID-19 vaccines in adults, including myocarditis, blood clots in the brain, and neurological disorders.
8. It is known that the challenge for researchers to identify new COVID-19 viral target proteins and then to adapt existing manufacturing platforms already shown to be safe for vaccines against other pathogens is already a daunting endeavor. However, using a new, rapid, but previously untested manufacturing technology (mRNA or DNA) introduced a second variable. Changing two variables simultaneously in a single experiment violates the classic scientific method. Here, the vaccines generated were comprised of active (COVID-19 viral sequences) and inactive components (manufacturing ingredients, including impurities), neither of which had a prior safety record in healthy adults and children.
9. It is known that RNA-based vaccines (Pfizer and Moderna) could trigger any number of autoimmune diseases, which can take years to manifest. This is because the resulting combination of viral and normal self-proteins expressed by any cell, which takes up mRNA, creates a brand-new target on normal cells, which the immune system potentially recognizes as foreign and attacks. mRNA also activates danger sensors in the primal immune system, which in turn indirectly promotes the release of pro-inflammation factors, specifically interferons, which have been associated with autoimmunity.
10. It is known that none of the mRNA vaccines has a built-in off switch to control where they travel in the body and how long they persist there. Published animal studies have shown traces of COVID-19 spike protein in the brain, heart and other vital organs, and that low levels of mRNA itself were detected in most tissues. The potential consequences of vaccines crossing the natural blood-brain barrier in children's developing brain are, or should be, of the upmost concern to all future humanity.
11. For most children, who rarely become seriously ill from COVID-19, particularly those with immunity from prior infection, for the City of Newton and the Holtzman Medical Group to forge ahead with currently available 'vaccines' (which are really still experimental gene therapy) makes no sense on any risk-benefit calculus.
12. Promoting COVID-19 vaccines for school-age children, in the same way as traditional vaccines, is comparing "apples to oranges." And certainly, they don't have a long enough safety history with the aforementioned second variable.
13. It is known that over 18,000 people have died from the COVID-19 'vaccine' -- according to the CDC -- AND THIS IS ONLY 1% OF ACTUAL DEATHS, as 99% are shockingly not reported. And beyond deaths, the total number of injuries is into the millions, including hospitalizations, urgent care visits, doctor's office visits, anaphylaxis, bell's palsy, miscarriages, heart attacks, myocarditis/pericarditis, permanent disability, thrombocytopenia/low platelet, severe allergic reactions, shingles, other life-threatening events -- and these are only the short-term complications.
14. In the absence of the Holtzman Medical Group (as well as the City of Newton) fully informing each and every child and parent attending the "COVID-19 vaccine clinics" -- prior to injection -- of information as set forth above or generally as set forth above, or information such that the above information can be obtained before injection, or providing information in order that there can be a serious consideration as to whether, under the above circumstances, it is worth trying to avoid symptoms of a disease (COVID-19) from which 99.97% of people recover, and which rarely affects children, there is no informed consent for the injection, and Holtzman Medical Group liability arises therefrom.
15. As a legal issue, forcing treatment on an unwilling person, such as injection with an experimental gene therapy, is no different from attacking that person with a knife. The legal term for a harmful or offensive touching without permission is "battery". Battery is not only a criminal offense, it can be the basis of a civil lawsuit.
16. The above "experimental gene therapy" has been labeled by the Holtzman Medical Group, as well as by the Mayor of Newton and the Newton Public Schools, as "COVID-19 Vaccines".
17. The key element of "battery" is that the touching be unauthorized, not that it be intended to harm the person.
18. "Medical Battery", unlike "Medical Malpractice", requires no doctor-patient relationship.
19. If the patient has been lied to about the treatment or there is other fraud in the informed consent, then the entire consent is invalid.
20. Harms and damages can arise from said injections of experimental gene therapy by their association with some or all of the following:
(1) Possible toxic graphene oxide nanoparticles
(2) Unknown duration bodily manufacture of biologically active spike proteins with strong coagulatory properties, circulating throughout the body damaging walls of blood vessels
(3) Immune system impairment
21. The Holtzman Medical Group under separate email has been provided with the undersigned's email chain of correspondence with the Mayor of Newton, Newton School Committee, Newton School and Superintendent Medical Advisory Committee and Massachusetts Secretary of Health and Human Services and Commissioners of Public Health, running from September 17, 2021 thru October 22, 2021. That goes into greater detail on the risks and likelihoods of the harms and damages of the injection with the aforesaid experimental gene therapy of Newton School and resident children down to the age of 5, and particularly in comparison with their monumentally much lesser risk and likelihood of harm and damage from the condition the injection is represented to address.
22. Since harms and damages may not manifest until some future date, this serves as notice of that fact, particularly in connection with any applicable statute of limitations, both civilly and criminally.
23. It is hoped that this notice will serve both to cause the Holtzman Medical Group immediately to reverse its guidance, recommendations and actions, and immediately to halt, and dissuade the City of Newton from further recommending or calling for, the injection of Newton School and other children with the experimental gene therapy, also identified as COVID-19 Vaccines.
24. This also serves to call upon the Holtzman Medical Group to call off its participation in the City of Newton's November 13 and 14 and following, pediatric COVID-19 vaccine clinics, and to so notify the City of Newton.
25. In accordance with the Hippocratic oath, a promise to practice "primum non nocere" meaning "first, do no harm," it is requested that the Holtzman Medical Group patiently wait for the completion of long term safety studies before rushing ahead blindly with a course of action which may cause irreparable harm to our children.
26. Reliance on the FDA or CDC will not suffice as a defense since in the United States there is only an emergency use authorization for the available said COVID-19 vaccines which is not valid where there are safe and effective therapeutics, nor is the City of Newton's election to silence any discussion on these therapeutics a defense for medical practitioners.
RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED, this 11th day of November, 2021.
James E. Epstein, Newton Citizen and Resident
October 29, 2021
CRIMES AGAINST HUMANITY RIGHT HERE IN NEWTON
MAYOR RUTHANNE FULLER:
DR. ASHISH JHA:
If you continue with this grotesque charade behind vaccinating Newton kids 5 to 11, both of you should one day be prosecuted for crimes against humanity.
READ THIS MAYOR FULLER AND NEWTON SCHOOL MEDICAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE (GROUP):
Jim Epstein
* * *
Ten red flags in the FDA's risk-benefit analysis of Pfizer's EUA application to inject American children 5 to 11 with its mRNA product
The FDA briefing document is preposterous junk science and it must be withdrawn immediately
Oct 25, 2022
Where to even begin with the FDA’s preposterous risk-benefit analysis of Pfizer’s mRNA COVID-19 “vaccine” in children ages 5 to 11?
Let’s start with my bona fides. I have a year of undergraduate statistics at one of the best liberal arts colleges in America (Swarthmore). I have a year of graduate statistics at the masters program rated #1 for policy analysis (UC Berkeley). And I have a Ph.D. in political economy from one of the top universities in the world (University of Sydney). My research focus is on corruption in the pharmaceutical industry so I’ve read scientific studies in connection with vaccines nearly every day for 5 years. Earlier in my career I worked professionally tearing apart shoddy cost-benefit analyses prepared by corporations that were trying to get tax breaks, contracts, and other concessions from local government. Suffice it to say I’ve thought a lot about risk-benefit analysis and I’m better equipped than most to read one of these documents.
The FDA’s risk-benefit analysis in connection with Pfizer’s Emergency Use Authorization (EUA) application to inject children ages 5 to 11 with their COVID-19 vaccine is one of the shoddiest documents I’ve ever seen.
Let’s take it from the top:
🚩 COVID-19 rates in children ages 5 to 11 are so low that there were ZERO cases of severe COVID-19 and ZERO cases of death from COVID in either the treatment (n= 1,518) or control group (n= 750). So any claims you see in the press about the Pfizer vaccine being “90% effective” in children are meaningless because they are referring to mild cases from which children usually recover quickly (and then have robust broad spectrum immunity). So there is literally no emergency in this population for which one could apply for Emergency Use Authorization. Pfizer’s application should be dead on arrival if the FDA actually followed the science and their own rules. We will return to this topic below.
🚩 Pfizer’s clinical trial in kids was intentionally undersized to hide harms. This is a well known trick of the pharmaceutical industry. The FDA even called them out on it earlier this summer and asked Pfizer to expand the trial and Pfizer just ignored them because they can. (Pfizer fudged it by importing data from a different study but this other study only monitored adverse outcomes for 17 days so if anything the new data polluted rather than clarified outcomes). To put it simply, if the rate of particular adverse outcome in kids as a result of this shot is 1 in 5,000 and the trial only enrolls 1,518 in the treatment group then one is unlikely to spot this particular harm in the clinical trial. Voilà “Safe & Effective(TM)”.
🚩 Pfizer only enrolled “participants 5-11 years of age without evidence of prior SARS-CoV-2 infection.” Does the Pfizer mRNA shot wipe out natural immunity and leave one worse-off than doing nothing as shown in this data from the British government? Pfizer has no idea because children with prior SARS-CoV-2 infection were excluded from this trial. This was by design. Toxic polluters have learned to not ask questions that they do not want the answers to, lest they wind up staring at their own smoking gun in a future court case.
According to an analysis by Alex Berenson:
“What the British are saying is they are now finding the vaccine interferes with your body’s innate ability after infection to produce antibodies against not just the spike protein but other pieces of the virus. Specifically, vaccinated people don’t seem to be producing antibodies to the nucleocapsid protein, the shell of the virus, which are a crucial part of the response in unvaccinated people. This means vaccinated people will be far more vulnerable to mutations in the spike protein EVEN AFTER THEY HAVE BEEN INFECTED AND RECOVERED ONCE (or more than once, probably). It also means the virus is likely to select for mutations that go in exactly that direction because those will essentially give it an enormous vulnerable population to infect. And it probably is still more evidence the vaccines may interfere with the development of robust long-term immunity post-infection.”
🚩 Did Pfizer LOSE CONTACT with 4.9% of their clinical trial participants? The FDA risk-benefit document states: “Among Cohort 1 participants, 95.1% had safety follow-up ≥2 months after Dose 2 at the time of the September 6, 2021 data cutoff.” So what happened with those 4.9% who did not have safety follow-up 2 months after Dose 2? Were they in the treatment or control group? We have no idea because Pfizer isn’t saying. Given the small size of the trial, failing to follow up with 4.9% of the participants potentially skews the results.
🚩 The follow up period was intentionally too short. This is another well-know trick of the pharmaceutical industry designed to hide harms. Cohort 1 appears to have been followed for 2 months, cohort 2 was only monitored for adverse events for 17 days. Many harms from vaccines including cancer and autoimmune disorders take much longer to show up. As the old saying goes, “you can have it quick or you can have it done right, but you cannot have both.” Pfizer chose quick.
🚩 The risk-benefit model created by the FDA only looks at one known harm from the Pfizer mRNA shot — myocarditis. But we know that the real world harms from the Pfizer mRNA shot go well beyond myocarditis and include anaphylaxis, Bell’s Palsy, heart attack, thrombocytopenia/ low platelet, permanent disability, shingles, and Guillain-Barré Syndrome (GBS) to name a few. Cancer, diabetes, endocrine disruption, and autoimmune disorders may show up later. But the FDA does not care about any of that because they have a vaccine to sell so they just ignore all of those factors in their model.
🚩 Pfizer intentionally wipes out the control group as soon as they can by vaccinating all of the kids who initially got the placebo. They claim that they are doing this for “ethical reasons”. But everyone knows that Pfizer’s true aim is to wipe out any comparison group so that there can be no long term safety studies. Wiping out the control group is a criminal act and yet Pfizer, Moderna, J&J, and AZ do this as standard practice with the blessing of the FDA/CDC.
🚩 Given all of the above, how on earth did the FDA claim any benefits at all from this shot? You should probably sit down for this part because it’s a doozy! Here’s the key sentence:
Vaccine effectiveness was inferred by immunobridging SARS-CoV-2 50% neutralizing antibody titers (NT50, SARS-CoV-2 mNG microneutralization assay).
Wait, what!? I’ll explain. There were ZERO cases of severe COVID-19 in the clinical trial of children ages 5 to 11. So Pfizer and the FDA just ignored all of the actual health outcomes (they had to, there is no emergency, so the application is moot). INSTEAD Pfizer switched to looking at antibodies in the blood. In general, antibodies are a poor predictor of immunity. And the antibodies in the blood of these 5 to 11 year old children tell us nothing because again, there were zero cases of severe COVID-19 in this study (none in the treatment group, none in the control group). So Pfizer had to get creative! What they came up with is “immuno-bridging”. Pfizer looked at the level of antibodies in the bloodwork of another study, this one involving people 16 to 25 years old, figured out the level of antibodies that seems to be protective in that population, then figured out how many kids ages 5 to 11 had similar levels of antibodies in their blood, and then came up with a number for how many cases, hospitalizations, ICU admissions, and deaths would be prevented by this shot in the 5 to 11 population in the future, based on the antibody levels and health outcomes from the 16 to 25 year old population. If your head hurts from that tortured logic, it should, because such chicanery is unprecedented in a risk-benefit analysis.
So when the FDA uses this tortured logic at the beginning of their briefing document, all of the calculations that stem from this will be flat out wrong. Not just wrong but preposterous and criminally wrong.
The whole ballgame comes down to Table 14 on page 34 of the FDA’s risk-benefit document. And there the red flags come fast and furious.
🚩 The FDA model only assesses the benefits of vaccine protection in a 6-month period after completion of two doses. Furthermore it assumes constant vaccine efficacy during that time period. This is problematic on several counts.
First, reducing mild cases in children is not a desired clinical outcome. As Dr. Geert Vanden Bossche points out, mass vaccination turns kids into shedders of more infectious variants.
"Under no circumstances should young and healthy people be vaccinated as it will only erode their protective innate immunity towards Coronaviruses (CoV) and other respiratory viruses. Their innate immunity normally/ naturally largely protects them and provides a kind of herd immunity in that it dilutes infectious CoV pressure at the level of the population, whereas mass vaccination turns them into shedders of more infectious variants. Children/ youngsters who get the disease mostly develop mild to moderate disease and as a result continue to contribute to herd immunity by developing broad and long-lived immunity. If you are vaccinated and get the disease, you may develop life-long immunity too but why would you take the risk of getting vaccinated, especially when you’re young and healthy? Firstly, there is the risk of potential side effects; secondarily, there is the ever increasing risk that your vaccinal antibodies will no longer be functional while still binding to the virus, thereby increasing the likelihood of ADE or even severe disease...."
Second, we know that vaccine efficacy in the month after the first dose is negative because it suppresses the immune system and it begins to wane after 4 months so all of the FDA’s estimates of vaccine efficacy are inflated.
Third, the harms of myocarditis from these shots will likely unfold over the course of years. Robert Malone, the inventor of mRNA technology notes that the FDA is admitting that children will be injected twice a year forever (hence the six month time frame in the FDA risk-benefit model). But the risks of “adverse events such as cardiomyopathy will be cumulative.” So any model that only looks at a six month time frame is hiding the true adverse event rate.
🚩 The FDA/Pfizer play fast and loose with their estimates of myocarditis. First they estimate “excess” (read: caused by the shot) myocarditis using data from the private “Optum health claim database” instead of the public VAERS system (p. 32). So it’s impossible for the public to verify their claims. Then, when it comes to estimating how many children with vaccine-induced myocarditis will be hospitalized and admitted to the ICU they use the Vaccine Safety Datalink (see page 33). Why switch to a different database for those estimates? Finally, there is no explanation for how they calculated “excess” myocarditis deaths, so they just put 0. Red flag, red flag, red flag.
The FDA estimates that there will be 106 extra myocarditis cases per 1 million double-jabbed children 5-11. There are 28,384,878 children ages 5 to 11 in the U.S. The Biden administration wants to inject Pfizer mRNA shots into all of them and has already purchased enough doses to do just that (even though only 1/3rd of parents want to jab their kids with this shot). So (if the Biden administration has its way) 106 excess myocarditis cases per 1 million x 28.38 million people would be 3,009 excess myocarditis cases post-vaccination if the Pfizer vaccine is approved.
And over the course of several years many of those children will die. Dr. Anthony Hinton (“Consultant Surgeon with 30 years experience in the NHS”) points out that myocarditis has a 20% fatality rate after 2 years and a 50% fatality rate after 5 years.
Dr Anthony Hinton @TonyHinton2016
Viral myocarditis results in 2 in 10 people dead after 2 years and 5 in 10 after 5 years. It’s not mild. It’s dead heart muscle. Neil Oliver @thecoastguy You can’t have “mild myocarditis” - in the same way you can’t be “a little bit pregnant”. October 20th 2021 2,286 Retweets4,450 Likes
So the FDA has it exactly backwards — they want to prevent mild COVID in children which reduces herd immunity and they just flat out lie about the harms from myocarditis.
I’ve taken the liberty to correct the FDA’s Table 14 with actual real world data and extended it over 5 years. It looks like this:
A study by Harvard Pilgrim Healthcare for the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services estimated that VAERS only captured 1% of actual vaccine injuries. Steve Kirsch has done elaborate modeling that puts the Under-Reporting Factor of COVID-19 vaccine deaths at 41 (so multiply the above numbers by 41). And myocarditis is just one of a multitude of possible harms from COVID-19 vaccines. Dr. Jessica Rose recently calculated an Under-Reporting Factor of 31 for all severe adverse events following vaccination.
Conclusion
The Pfizer vaccine fails any honest risk-benefit assessment in connection with its use in children ages 5 to 11. The FDA’s risk-benefit analysis of Pfizer’s mRNA vaccine in children ages 5 to 11 is shoddy. It used tortured logic (that would be rejected by any proper academic journal) in order to reach a predetermined result that is not based in science. The FDA briefing document is a work of fiction and it must be withdrawn immediately. If the FDA continues with this grotesque charade it will cause irreparable harms to children and the FDA leadership will one day be prosecuted for crimes against humanity.
Want to share your concerns with the members of the VRBPAC? Here's a link to an article with additional context and all of their contact information:
[Updated to add:]
🚩 An astute reader pointed out that on page 14, the FDA explains that Pfizer has changed the ingredients in their mRNA vaccine. They write:
To provide a vaccine with an improved stability profile, the Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 Vaccine for use in children 5-11 years of age uses tromethamine (Tris) buffer instead of the phosphate-buffered saline (PBS) as used in the previous formulation and excludes sodium chloride and potassium chloride.
I’m deeply skeptical of this account (I doubt this has anything to do with an “improved stability profile”) and invite others to weigh in on this. I also recall that tromethamine has a long and troubled history and invite readers to dig into this further (I’m happy to post additional links as they become available).
The FBA’s flawed risk-benefit analysis was written by:
Hong Yang
Biologist
DHHS/FDA/CBER/OBE
Building, WO71, Room 5338
Mail stop: HFM-210
Silver Spring MD 20993-0002
phone: (240) 402-8836
fax: (301) 595-1240
Hong.Yang@fda.hhs.gov
and
Richard Forshee
Associate Director
DHHS/FDA/CBER/OBE
Building, WO71, Room 5342
Silver Spring MD 20993-0002
phone: (240) 402-8631
fax: (301) 595-1240
Richard.Forshee@fda.hhs.gov
PLEA TO MAYOR FULLER -- PLEASE DON'T VACCINATE OUR KIDS
Three important articles below:
Government’s Official Statistics: If You Get Vaxxed, You Will NEVER Achieve Full Immunity Ever Again
The UK government has spilled the beans and stated that the vaccinated population will never acquire full natural immunity.
In the Week 42 COVID-19 vaccine surveillance report, the UK Health Security Agency confessed that “N antibody levels appear to be lower in people who acquire infection following two doses of vaccination.”
From the report, we can learn that the antibody drop is permanent.
What’s this mean? Several things, all bad,” stated Alex Berenson. “We know the vaccines do not stop infection or transmission of the virus (in fact, the report shows elsewhere that vaccinated adults are now being infected at much HIGHER rates than the unvaccinated).”
“What the British are saying is they are now finding the vaccine interferes with your body’s innate ability after infection to produce antibodies against not just the spike protein but other pieces of the virus. Specifically, vaccinated people don’t seem to be producing antibodies to the nucleocapsid protein, the shell of the virus, which is a crucial part of the response in unvaccinated people.”
The unvaccinated will gain immunity to all strains of the virus after only one natural infection with it.
“It also means the virus is likely to select for mutations that go in exactly that direction because those will essentially give it an enormous vulnerable population to infect,” Berenson further warns. “And it probably is still more evidence the vaccines may interfere with the development of robust long-term immunity post-infection.”
Big Pharma can’t be trusted! Don’t read their reports and receipts!
BOMBSHELL: UK Government Data: 70% Of COVID Deaths Are DOUBLE-VACCINATED!
mRNA Vaccines weaken the immune system, even after recovery?
BY ZACH HEILMAN
OCTOBER 24, 2021
According to a report from the United Kingdom, it appears that the Covid-19 vaccine inhibits the body’s ability to naturally produce antibodies making vaccinated people more susceptible to catching the virus.The information can be found in the UK Government’s most recent, Covid-19 Vaccine Surveillance Report. The report states that “N antibody levels appear to be lower in people who acquire infection following two doses of vaccination.” According to vaccine researcher Alex Berenson, this essentially means that vaccinated people who have become infected will never acquire complete immunity to the coronavirus._________________________
By Sarah Mae Saliong Oct 19, 2021
mRNA Technology Inventor Says Fully Vaccinated People Are ‘Super-Spreaders’ for COVID
Dr. Robert Malone, the inventor of mRNA technology used in mRNA vaccines, said that it's those who got the experimental COVID shots that are the real "super-spreaders" and not those who didn't get jabbed as totalitarian states and establishment media claimed.
"The idea that if you have a workplace where everybody's vaccinated, you're not going to have virus spread is totally false. A total lie," said Dr. Malone on a recent episode of the podcast The Hidden Gateway.
During host Jesston Williams' interview with Dr. Malone, they discussed the invention and initial running tests of mRNA technology, how government agencies have been using violence and intimidation to increase vaccination rates, and how public health agencies lack the necessary and relevant safety and efficacy data for a global vaccination program. Also brought up was the idea of governments and public health agencies misleading the public "for their own good."
One of the most interesting things Malone said in his interview was his claim that those who had gotten the experimental shot as "super-spreaders" because of their propensity to infect others.
LifeSite News quoted him as saying: "If you consider the scientific fact that vaccinated people have less symptoms than the unvaccinated, but can still easily spread disease, consider your fellow vaccinated worker, whose unvaccinated son brought the disease home and gave it to him ... He might not have any symptoms ... but he'll definitely be producing the virus. And he's going to say, hey, I can go to work today. But he's going to be spreading the virus like crazy."
Malone also said that if the government refuses to tell people about the short and long-term risks of the experimental shots and refuses to tell them the truth about what's actually happening because they believe people won't be able to take the news, then that is basically "the noble lie."
The "noble lie," however, was condemned as "paternalistic authoritarianism" by Malone.
He explained that governance-by-lying dates back to Plato and Ancient Greek philosophy which states that it's "okay for politicians and people in authority positions to lie to the general public because they have special knowledge and ability to understand things ... and the general public can't cope with that level of information. And so it's okay to lie to them."
"I really disagree with this line of thinking," Malone remarked. "Yet it has been public policy in the United States and worldwide in public health for a very long time."
He also maintained that personal freedom and bodily autonomy matter, regardless of one's political inclinations.
He further highlighted that the physicians whose licenses were revoked or were cancelled for failing to adhere to the official COVID narratives were not "spring chickens" whose views should be suppressed when it comes to proper patient care.
Concerning the existence of the COVID virus, Malone urged the audience not to be afraid and to avoid falling prey to fear-mongering news agencies. He cited Norway's success in containing the virus, and how they now consider COVID to be comparable to seasonal flu.
Nonetheless, Malone, like other knowledgeable doctors, stressed the importance of early treatment.
"Don't let fear dominate your lives," he reiterated, adding that it's what the ruling elites want to happen in order to maintain control over the populace.
October 22, 2021
DUPLICATE VIA CERTIFIED MAIL
RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED
Marylou Sudders, MSW, ACSWSecretary, Health and Human ServicesCommonwealth of Massachusetts1 Ashburton Place, Boston, MA 02108
Dear Secretary Sudders:
I am a citizen of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts residing in Newton.
I am deeply concerned about the catastrophic health risk from the Covid-19 vaccine program currently being implemented throughout the Commonwealth, mostly by cities and towns. This includes state and local Government employee mandates.
Since you have authority over the Department of Public Health with whose Acting Commissioner I have just corresponded (below), I ask that you also take the time to review the below thread of correspondence with the City of Newton.
Importantly, not one Newton or School official has ruled out, yet alone substantively replied to, what are the three major categories of vaccine concern:
(1) Toxic graphene oxide nanoparticles
(2) Unknown duration manufacture of biologically active spike proteins with strong coagulatory properties, circulating throughout the body damaging walls of blood vessels
(3) Immune system impairment
Since all three aspects have been associated with a considerable list of serious, sometimes fatal, adverse reactions, I feel the vaccine program must immediately be suspended until the three categories of risk are ruled out. Any risk assessment needs to weigh it against the otherwise extremely low Covid-19 morbidity and mortality risk, especially if early therapeutics are promoted.
I'm aware that a majority of residents have already received one or two doses of the vaccine. Moreover, potential adverse health reaction may not manifest until a later date. Nevertheless, boosters are now being promoted to the previously vaccinated as well as initial shots to children down to the age of
5. Clearly there remains immediate need for the Commonwealth to suspend vaccinations, including all employee mandates, pending a full assessment of the above three risk categories.Because of the colossal health implications, I feel the level of importance for the Commonwealth is unprecedented. Any effort to avoid responsibility by shifting it to the unvaccinated must be soundly rejected. I look forward to hearing back that your office and the Commonwealth more than share these vital concerns and will take the appropriate actions.
Sincerely,
Jim Epstein
cc: Massachusetts Public Health Acting and Associate CommissionersNewton Mayor FullerDr. Jha and Newton Medical Advisory Committee MembersNewton School Committee Members and SuperintendentNewton City Council Members
October 20, 2021
DUPLICATE VIA CERTIFIED MAIL RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED
Margaret R. Cooke, Acting Commissioner Massachusetts Department of Public Health
250 Washington Street, Boston, MA 02108
DUPLICATE VIA CERTIFIED MAIL RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED
Lindsey Tucker, Associate Commissioner, Massachusetts Department of Public Health 250 Washington Street, Boston, MA 02108
Dear Acting Commissioner Cooke and Associate Commissioner Tucker:
I respectfully request that the Massachusetts Department of Public Health carefully review the below record of 27 separate pieces of correspondence with Newton elected officials and their Medical Advisory Committee concerning the City's and School's Covid-19 vaccine program.
As you can see, it does not appear that I will be able to secure a substantive response from anyone at the municipal level to my repeated concerns. Nor will I be able to get any reexamination of Newton's vaccine mandates required of employees. Nor any reexamination of excessive and persistent Mayoral recommendations that everyone get vaccines down to the age of 5 -- all inaugurating the need for more and more boosters down the road.
Therefore, I am reaching out to you to intervene, but not only for that reason. I am because of reports that the sharply increasing worldwide hospitalizations of the fully vaccinated are more than Covid-19 vaccine "breakthroughs". Rather, it is the increasing morbidity and mortality of the fully vaccinated whose natural immunity is being further extinguished with each and every injection of the self-replicating RNA elicited antigen-specific antibody, ultimately resulting in something akin to Acquired Immunodeficiency Syndrome (AIDS). And since this would be instigated by the vaccine injection itself, this can be called “Injected Immunodeficiency Syndrome” or “IIDS.”
In any case, because of these unprecedented risks and dangers to all residents of the Commonwealth, I feel your Department immediately must look into this possibility, and if you cannot rule it out, advise the Governor immediately to suspend further vaccinations.
Given the otherwise extremely low rate of Covid-19 morbidity and mortality, especially if the Commonwealth would allow and encourage the early use of available safe and effective therapeutics (rather than "vaxx" or else), anything less than a suspension of further vaccinations under these circumstances is malfeasance.
Actually it would be so utterly reckless and unconscionable that I feel officials of the Massachusetts Department of Public Health would be held fully accountable.
Please reply that you will immediately and thoroughly address this.
Sincerely, Jim Epstein
cc:Newton Mayor FullerDr. Jha and Newton Medical Advisory Committee MembersNewton School Committee Members and SuperintendentNewton City Council Members
October 16, 2021
Honorable Ruthanne FullerMayor, City of NewtonDear Mayor Fuller:Promotional material on your Re-Election Campaign arrived at my home yesterday (below). It touts your "detailed regular Mayor's Updates" to keep "residents informed about...how to get everyone in our City vaccinated..."
You remain steadfast -- actually the entire City Government and School Committee remain steadfast -- in not replying to my repeated requests to look at current medical and scientific substance. That is, beyond your reliance on Dr. Jha.
Hence, I will conclude that you and the City of Newton and Public Schools will provide nothing regarding my concerns. Instead, you will simply continue your aim "to get everyone in our City vaccinated."
Here are a few citations (absent from mainstream media) again showing your aim's unprecedented risks and dangers:https://theexpose.uk/2021/10/15/its-worse-than-we-thought-fully-covid-vaccinated-ade/
https://www.vaccinewars.com/2021-10-14-more-covid-vaccine-deaths-in-10-months.html#
https://photos.app.goo.gl/evKG48DrLtjw9T719
https://photos.google.com/share/AF1QipN3RNLe6QJrvtlyUquqWTfYEX6FDVME1Xy4KK8FbognSTIEJNDn4YmpMyizuGrk3Q?key=VWxnOU5uZGlYY3FHWlE3aUNGY05KVDNRUmgtZ2x3
https://dreddymd.com/2021/10/16/johns-hopkins-proves-covid-19-vaccines-spikes-in-infections-and-deaths/
Agree or disagree, your refusal even to have examined and respond is noted.
You may feel cushioned within your Democrat liberal political and media envelope. However, titanic national and global political and financial changes are approaching. And the role of Covid-19 will be exposed.
I feel I have more than demonstrated my persistence. My plan is to continue with equal persistence after the public reveal to seek accountability of those in local government who have been partnering in this man-made disaster.
Sincerely,
Jim Epstein
cc: Dr. Jha and Newton Medical Advisory Committee Members, Newton School Committee Members and Superintendent, Newton City Council Members
_________________________
Rec'd U.S. Mail, Oct. 15, 2021
OUR FRIENDS AT
110 MANCHESTER RD
NEWTON MA 02461-1123
Throughout COVID, Ruthanne Fuller has set a standard for effective, transparent leadership.
With detailed regular "Mayor's Updates," she's kept residents informed about exactly how Newtonians have been impacted by the pandemic, what the City is doing about it, and how to get everyone in our City vaccinated...
Ruthanne Fuller for Mayor
RuthanneFuller.com
October 15, 2021
Honorable Ruthanne Fuller
Mayor, City of Newton
Dear Mayor Fuller:
Your October 14 Update (below) features your "fascinating" hour of "information and insights" from Dr. Ashish Jha.
However, to those in Newton not subject to your constraints, it is misinformation. Most of what Dr. Jha stated on Covid-19 vaccines is 100% wrong or misleading by omission. And predicating health-related city and school-wide recommendations and determinations upon those misrepresentations is unacceptable.
Dr. Jha utterly dismisses concerns about Covid-19 vaccine safety -- says they are "exceedingly safe." Dr. Jha utterly ignores therapeutics. Dr. Jha utterly avoids that vaccine risks of morbidity and mortality exceed treatable Covid-19 risks.
I feel that your next Update needs to address these critical questions for Newton residents. Since you and Dr. Jha will not do so, I respectfully ask that your next Update provide a link to the October 1, 2021, one hour presentation by Dr. Peter A. McCullough, MD. It is in the public domain and linked here: https://brightlightnews.com/winning-the-war-against-therapeutic-nihilism-dr-peter-mccullough-2021-10-01/
It is clear that Dr. McCullough's professional credentials, area of expertise and experience, publications, and medical practice, are exceedingly more relevant -- than Dr. Jha's "worldwide expertise in public health policy." This should be a question of science and safety, not a question of policy and politics which sadly frame Dr. Jha's "vaxx or else" role.
Dr. McCullough warns against what is "therapeutic nihilism" and a "rush to replace trusted treatments with untested novel therapies."
Please do watch Dr. Peter McCullough's one hour discussion. It features an "extensive rundown on everything Covid-19 vaccines, from safety and efficacy to the fraudulent 'approval' of the Pfizer vaccine."
After watching Dr. McCullough's presentation juxtaposed to that of Dr. Jha, it seems hard to imagine you will not find unconscionable Dr. Jha's unyielding agenda to inoculate all Newton children (actually all Americans, the entire world) down to the age of 5. That is, with a 'vaccine' yet fully tested as safe under normal protocol, and solely authorized for emergency use in the absence of currently available safe and effective therapeutics which Dr. Jha has advocated withholding.
Sincerely,
Jim Epstein
cc: Dr. Jha and Newton Medical Advisory Committee Members, Newton School Committee Members and Superintendent, Newton City Council Members
From: Mayor Ruthanne Fuller
To: James Epstein
Sent: Thu, Oct 14, 2021
Subject: C-19, Dr. Jha...
Thursday, October 14, 2021
Mayor's Update
Dr. Ashish Jha spent a fascinating hour with me at NewTV on Tuesday evening answering questions from Newton residents about COVID-19. As a worldwide expert in public health policy, Dean of the Brown University School of Public Health, a member of our school Medical Advisory Committee, and parent of students in the Newton Public Schools, he provided a lot of up to date information and insights.
Some highlights are: People who are fully vaccinated are dramatically less likely to spread the virus even if they are infected; Delta is so contagious that every American will likely come in contact with it; vaccines for 5 to 11 year olds will likely be available during the first week of November.
Dr. Jha’s advice about Halloween? Maybe don’t host a party with 30 kids inside, but go ahead and have a blast trick or treating outdoors.
Watch our full discussion:
...
Mayor Ruthanne Fuller
1000 Commonwealth Avenue, Newton, MA 02459
Sent by rfuller@newtonma.gov
October 14, 2021
Dr. Ashish Jha
Spokesperson, Newton Medical Advisory Committee
Dean, Brown University School of Public Health
Dear Dr. Jha,
Regrettably your interview with Mayor Fuller did not address any of the specific concerns raised and surrounding Covid vaccine safety and effectiveness (including vaccine side-effects vs. smaller Covid-19 morbidity/mortality rate). That is, beyond your remarking that the vaccines are "exquisitely safe", "incredibly good", with "no negative effects", and supplanting an unvaccinated "immune system that's naive".
With all due respect, I hope there is complete objectivity on your part since you direct total focus on promoting vaccines. Again, with all due respect, I must ask due to the millions of dollars secured by Brown University's School of Public Health in Covid Vaccine Study Grants. And I certainly hope there is no association at your end dating to bioengineering Covid-19 and the pandemic.
In any case, to determine that the Newton Medical Advisory Committee, to at least some extent, examined these critical questions, can you simply review and comment on the substance reported in these three sources:
1. "Long Term Damage from Covid Vaccination" May 30, 2021
https://undercurrents723949620.wordpress.com/2021/05/30/long-term-damage-from-covid-vaccination/
2. "Best Explanation Why the Covid Jabs are Killer Shots" August 30, 2021
https://rumble.com/vlvhy5-best-explanation-ive-seen-about-why-the-covid-jabs-are-killer-shots.html [Or Alt:]
http://zwies.net/index.php/2021/09/12/best-explanation-ive-seen-about-why-the-covid-jabs-are-killer-shots/
3. "Are the Covid Shots Working?" October 13, 2021
https://media.mercola.com/ImageServer/Public/2021/October/PDF/are-the-covid-shots-working-pdf.pdf
In doing so, kindly comment on the question I asked right prior to the interview citing "Covid Deaths Before and After Vaccination Programs, DATA SOURCE Johns Hopkins University Coronavirus Research Center" September 11, 2021. See:
[YouTube not yet censored]
https://photos.app.goo.gl/evKG48DrLtjw9T719 [Photos]
https://photos.google.com/share/AF1QipN3RNLe6QJrvtlyUquqWTfYEX6FDVME1Xy4KK8FbognSTIEJNDn4YmpMyizuGrk3Q?key=VWxnOU5uZGlYY3FHWlE3aUNGY05KVDNRUmgtZ2x3
Please address SUBSTANCE rather than editorializing on the particular source(s) provided.
Thank you.
Sincerely,
Jim Epstein
cc:
Newton Mayor Fuller, Newton Medical Advisory Committee Members, Newton School Committee Members and Superintendent, Newton City Council Members
_________________________
October 12, 2021
Honorable Ruthanne Fuller
Mayor, City of Newton
Dear Mayor Fuller:
I understand you will be interviewing Newton Medical Advisory Committee Spokesperson, Dr. Ashish Jha, later today on NewTV.
As you know, Dr. Jha gained prominence as "network TV’s everyman expert on Covid...[who] at the height of his stardom...was doing 10 to 12 TV appearances a day, though he’s pared back to about four or so now [as of May 2021]." https://www.statnews.com/2021/05/18/how-ashish-jha-became-network-tvs-everyman-expert-on-covid/
Dr. Jha, in both television appearances and before the House and Senate was harshly critical of the Trump FDA's Emergency Use Authorization (EUA) for Covid-19 vaccines. https://docs.house.gov/meetings/IF/IF02/20200930/111063/HHRG-116-IF02-Wstate-JhaA-20200930.pdf
https://www.hsgac.senate.gov › imo › media › doc › Testimony-Jha-2020-11-19.pdf
That is, before arrival of the new administration, whereupon Dr. Jha found EUA for Covid-19 vaccines fully acceptable.
In any event, I hope you will have an opportunity to query Dr. Jha about the drastically sharp increase in Covid-19 deaths after, compared to before, the initiation of the mass vaccine programs, data compiled for 40 nations by the Johns Hopkins University Coronavirus Research Center:
Please see both:
https://photos.app.goo.gl/evKG48DrLtjw9T719
Thank you.
Jim Epstein
cc: Newton Medical Advisory Committee Members, Newton School Committee Members and Superintendent, Newton City Council Members
October 9, 2021
Honorable Ruthanne Fuller
Mayor, City of Newton
Dr. Ashish Jha
Dean, Brown University School of Public Health
Member, Newton Medical Advisory Committee
Dear Mayor Fuller and Dr. Jha:
Dr. Jha, I address this correspondence to you as spokesman for Newton's Medical Advisory Committee. I am advised the Mayor will not make unilateral Covid decisions without guidance and recommendations from your group of professionals.
I am still hoping the City of Newton will take steps immediately to halt Covid shots for under-30s despite it jeopardizing the City's receipt of federal and state monies. Norway and Iceland have joined Sweden, Denmark and Finland in the ban due to inflammation of heart muscle and surrounding tissues, arrhythmias, myocarditis and pericarditis.
But more than that, there is life-long increased risk of blood clots in the heart, stroke and heart attack. That, while Covid-19 infection rates continue to soar in nations with the highest vaccination rates, most recently Singapore.
There seems to be a bottom line here, which Dr. Jha, I feel you will agree as a professional. The shot gives absolutely no protection against infection. It is the innate immune system that protects you from infection by using dendritic cells, T-cells, and natural killer cells without antibodies ever becoming involved. This shot has one goal. And that goal is to make antibodies. These antibodies circulate inside of you and cannot prevent an infection. They can only react to something that has already gotten inside of you. They cannot keep something out. The shot more than substantially decreases the ability of your innate immune system to keep viruses out (including with emerging evidence, cancer). And a booster shot will reduce it even more. Even worse, the antibodies that are created by this shot can no longer neutralize variants and actually enhance the virus' ability to infect you.
It should be painfully obvious by now that fully vaccinated people are getting sick and this will continue to get worse if you continue to keep trying to jab people while a virus is trying to spread. The variants are emerging from the vaccinated population. The so-called "vaccine" is still being administered in what has been an emergency use authorization. It is not FDA approved. The FDA approved a biological licensing application for a product called COMIRNATY. The application was approved, not the product. COMIRNATY is not available in the United States.
Therefore, by law, you cannot force people to take this drug without informed consent and without animal trials to prove that it is safe.
Mayor Fuller, insofar as mandating vaccines for City and School employees, you and the School Committee are in violation of the United States Constitution and the Nuremburg Code. You and the School Committee will be held accountable.
Sincerely,
Jim Epstein
cc: Newton Medical Advisory Committee Members, Newton School Committee Members and Superintendent, Newton City Council Members
P.S. Many consider Covid-19 manmade in a Chinese lab as a bio-engineered weapon (as part of a bio-engineered pandemic). If the 'vaccine' were part of that bio-engineering, consider the implications.
_________________________
October 8, 2021
Vicki Danberg
Newton City Councilor at Large, Ward 6
Dear City Councilor Danberg,
My below October 7 letter urges the Mayor to halt Covid shots for under-30s.
Nonetheless, the Mayor persists with her later Update: "Currently, all who are 12 years of age and older are eligible for a vaccine. People ages 12 to 17 can only get the Pfizer vaccine. People age 18 and older can get any vaccine." She even suggests predicating the lifting of masking on "the availability of vaccines for our youngsters."
In your October 4 message you dismiss my views, you "do not share them, so will continue to join the Mayor in encouraging residents to vaccinate and obtain their boosters when appropriate."
In view of the under-30s ban, now including Finland as well as Sweden and Denmark, is this still your view? More specifically, does your view apply to Newton residents under the age of 30, or 18? Or, more particularly, does it apply to Newton male residents under the age of 30, or 18?
If you now concur in my concerns, will you immediately carry them to the full City Council membership for attention?
Will you now carry them in any case to the the Newton Medical Advisory Committee for immediate attention?
Thank you.
Jim Epstein
cc: Newton Mayor Fuller, Newton Medical Advisory Committee Members, Newton School Committee Members and Superintendent, Newton City Council Members
October 7, 2021
Honorable Ruthanne Fuller
Mayor, City of Newton
Dear Mayor Fuller:
For your immediate attention, from NEWSWEEK October 6, 2021:
“The Moderna COVID-19 vaccine was recently suspended for people under 30 in Sweden due to a slight chance of heart inflammation”, the Associated Press reported.
"Sweden's Public Health Agency said in a statement that the shot was paused because of "signals of an increased risk of side effects such as inflammation of the heart muscle or the pericardium." However, the agency said the risk of being affected "is very small."
"U.S. and European regulators caution, however, that both the Moderna and Pfizer vaccines appear linked to a rare reaction in teenagers and young adults -- chest pain and heart inflammation.
"The data points to an increased incidence in connection with vaccination against COVID-19, mainly in adolescents and young adults and mainly in boys and men."
The ban has been extended to Denmark.
https://news.yahoo.com/sweden-pauses-moderna-covid-vaccine-113809877.html
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2021-10-07/sweden-denmark-moderna-covid-vaccine-pause/100519714
https://www.foxbusiness.com/healthcare/sweden-denmark-stop-moderna-vaccines-heart-condition
While the chance of heart inflammation (myocarditis and pericarditis) is "small", "COVID's miniscule morbidity and mortality rate" for adolescents and young adults is far smaller. Any increase in incidents of myocarditis and pericarditis in Newton is unacceptable and more than arguably will be attributable to your vaccination effort.
Mayor Fuller, you need promptly to end your vaccine campaign directed to young adults, despite the loss of that requisite for federal and state monies.
I hope you agree. In any event, NEWTON'S MEDICAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE NEEDS TO WEIGH IN ON THIS IMMEDIATELY.
Thank you.
Jim Epstein
cc: Newton Medical Advisory Committee Members, Newton School Committee Members and Superintendent, Newton City Council Members
P.S. Correct your public misinformation (below) that the "Delta variant has morphed into the pandemic of the unvaccinated."
P.P.S. 76% of September Covid-19 deaths are vax breakthroughs – Vermont Daily Chronicle https://vermontdailychronicle.com/2021/09/30/76-of-september-covid-19-deaths-are-vaxxed-breakthroughs
_________________________
October 6, 2021
Honorable Ruthanne Fuller
Mayor, City of Newton
Dear Mayor Fuller:
As you know, the School Committee has passed responsibility to the Medical Advisory Committee for COVID decisions. You have now essentially followed the same tact. With all due respect, however, yours is fraudulent.
In your October 4, 2021 Mayor's Update, you elect to state: "The highly contagious “Delta” variant has morphed into, in the words of Newton’s own Rochelle Walensky, “the pandemic of the unvaccinated.”"
However, CDC Director Walensky was roundly called out for her lies on this. "...the CDC included hospitalization and mortality data from January through June 2021. It does not include more recent data or data related to the Delta variant, which is now the most prevalent strain in circulation. The problem is, the vast majority of the United States population was unvaccinated during that timeframe. ...those receiving an initial dose in June, for example, won’t be “fully vaccinated” until eight weeks later, sometime in July or August. By using statistics from a time period when the U.S. as a whole was largely unvaccinated, the CDC is now claiming we’re in a “pandemic of the unvaccinated,” in an effort to demonize those who still have not agreed to receive this experimental gene modification injection."
https://sungod64.wordpress.com/2021/10/02/the-lies-behind-the-pandemic-of-unvaxxed/
Moreover, a detailed new California study confirms what I repeatedly have been saying, that vaccinated individuals are more susceptible to COVID variant infections than unvaccinated. In addition, the increase in the frequency of more antibody-resistant strains in the population correlates with the increase in the frequency of vaccination in the population.
https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.08.19.21262139v1.full
Please publicly correct the record.
Sincerely,
Jim Epstein
cc: Newton Medical Advisory Committee Members, Newton School Committee Members and Superintendent, Newton City Council Members
October 4, 2021
Vicki Danberg
Newton City Councilor at Large, Ward 6
Dear City Councilor Danberg,
Since the very beginning of this attempt at dialogue, I have not received even one word on substance. Your latest letter as well, with simply "I don't share your views."No substantive comment, no substantive refutation, no substantive anything.If you or any City Official or Medical Advisory Committee Member would at least address the documented points, and address with substance. And, Councilor, why is there no information provided to residents on therapeutics? Please, WILL SOME CITY OFFICIAL, SCHOOL OFFICIAL, OR MEDICAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE MEMBER RESPOND WITH SUBSTANCE?
Thank you.
Sincerely, Jim Epstein
cc: Newton Medical Advisory Committee Members, Newton City Council Members, Newton Mayor Fuller, Newton School Committee Members and Superintendent
From: Victoria Danberg
To: James Epstein
Cc: rfuller@newtonma.gov; ruthanne@ruthannefuller.com; deanofpublichealth@brown.edu; mahrokh_irani@brown.edu; jjhlarson@yahoo.com; sbnelson@mgh.harvard.edu; sbnelson@partners.org; brendaanders@gmail.com; erubin@hsph.harvard.edu; fmalafronte@hsph.harvard.edu; ksadler@mgh.harvard.edu; ksadler@partners.org; oneeka.williams@gmail.com; oneekawilliams@gmail.com; drdeedeedynamo@gmail.com; zalez77@verizon.net; citycouncil@newtonma.gov; salbright@newtonma.gov; jkrintzman@newtonma.gov; dcrossley@newtonma.gov; vdanberg@newtonma.gov; mlaredo@newtonma.gov; rlipof@newtonma.gov; aleary@newtonma.gov; akelley@newtonma.gov; lgentile@newtonma.gov; adowns@newtonma.gov; rwgrossman@newtonma.gov; dkalis@newtonma.gov; msgreenberg@newtonma.gov; enorton@newtonma.gov; cmarkiewicz@newtonma.gov; bnoel@newtonma.gov; lbaker@newtonma.gov; jmalakie@newtonma.gov; bhumphrey@newtonma.gov; hryan@newtonma.gov; abowman@newtonma.gov; pwright@newtonma.gov; joliver@newtonma.gov; tlucas@newtonma.gov; schoolcommittee@newton.k12.ma.us; ruth_goldman@newton.k12.ma.us; goldmanr@newton.k12.ma.us; raycanadab@newton.k12.ma.us; albrightma@newton.k12.ma.us; shena@newton.k12.ma.us; olszewskit@newton.k12.ma.us; prennere@newton.k12.ma.us; shieldsk@newton.k12.ma.us; millermattsc@newton.k12.ma.us; David_Fleishman@newton.k12.ma.us
Sent: Mon, Oct 4, 2021 11:18 pm
Subject: Re: "Vaxx or Else" Campaign
Dear Mr. Epstein,
Thank you for your comments. I am not answering your letter to the Mayor. I am responding to your letter to me. While I respect your views on vaccination as your own, I do not share them, so will continue to join the Mayor in encouraging residents to vaccinate and obtain their boosters when appropriate.
Again, thank you for taking the time to comment.
Vicki Danberg, Councilor at Large, Ward 6
October 4, 2021
Honorable Ruthanne Fuller Mayor, City of Newton
Dear Mayor Fuller, You elected to announce in your Update of today, October 4, 2021: "The highly contagious Delta variant has morphed into...the pandemic of the unvaccinated.” Please confirm whether or not you consulted the Medical Advisory Committee in conveying this medical judgment and, if so, whether those doctors concur. A response now seems critical in view of (1) the division you are encouraging from City Hall between vaccinated and unvaccinated residents and (2) your election to emphasize a point precisely opposite of the data, information and sourcing compiled in the below thread.
Thank you.
Jim Epstein
cc: Newton Medical Advisory Committee Members, Newton City Council Members, Newton School Committee Members and Superintendent.
October 3, 2021
Vicki Danberg Newton City Councilor at Large, Ward 6
Dear City Councilor Danberg,
I have your "spread the word" booster shot message. In her October 1, 2021 Update, the Mayor urges boosters for large categories of residents beyond just the 65+ age group. She carefully attempts to differentiate the booster from a third dose of the original vaccine. In her October 1, 2021 Update, the Mayor urges boosters for large categories of residents beyond just the 65+ age group. She carefully attempts to differentiate the booster from a third dose of the original vaccine. She links the latest CDC report. That report acknowledges there is "significant decline in vaccine effectiveness against infection for mRNA products in the Delta period." It acknowledges that "vaccines may be less effective in preventing infection or symptomatic illness due to...the Delta variant."
This goes a substantial way toward my exact point down-thread. The vaccine itself is responsible for infection increase during "the Delta period" and from "the Delta variant."
As I stated below, "the vaccinated are trading their overall natural COVID immunities for a variant-specific immunity blocking their natural immunity to other variants -- predicating a need for booster after booster." In other words, boosters forever. Each different booster accelerates further variant, with greater lethality mutating around that particular booster.
Moreover, the loss of natural immunity is in addition to the vaccine's other serious health complications and risks, now fully documented despite compromised media attempts to silence.
For the Mayor still to endeavor to expand -- as she essentially does in her October 1 Update -- the affliction of known vaccine induced permanent health dangers and life long boosters to those remaining unvaccinated, especially Newton youth currently over 12 years of age, plus now even a third dose of the original vaccine for some "immune compromised", plus scheduling mandatory vaccines for all City and Public School employees, in what is a "Vaxx or Else" campaign, is beyond unconscionable.
This is especially egregious weighted against COVID's miniscule morbidity and mortality rate. What further proof do you need that the Mayor's aims and concerns are political, rather than health, when she simultaneously censors all information on available safe therapeutics which fully would obviate vaccines? Or is complicit in the blackout of India's dramatic Ivermectin COVID eradication?
There are those in power, beyond Newton, who it appears may have diabolical aims. Remember, COVID is a lab created bioweapon and President Trump declared it an Act of War by the Chinese CCP, subjecting American co-conspirators to charges of treason and exposure to civil liability. It may already be too late for the Mayor, but other Newton officials should play no part in this. The "Crime Against Humanity" declaration currently has over 9,200 (and counting) doctor and scientist signatories.
And if there is any doubt as to the actual status of the 'Biden Administration' vis-a-vis President Trump, COVID as an "Act of War", and the November 3 election, I suggest that all Newton residents fully inform themselves. See https://www.devolution.link/
I ask that you carry this matter to Newton's Medical Advisory Committee and the full City Council. Ask that they call upon the Mayor immediately to stop.
Please spread the word!
Sincerely,
Jim Epstein
cc: Newton Medical Advisory Committee
Newton City Council, Newton Mayor Fuller, Newton School Committee and Superintendent
P.S. See, e.g.
https://rumble.com/vlvhy5-best-explanation-ive-seen-about-why-the-covid-jabs-are-killer-shots.html
https://undercurrents723949620.wordpress.com/2021/05/30/long-term-damage-from-covid-vaccination
https://stateofthenation.co
https://dreddymd.com/2021/09/29/moderna-ceo-says-booster-shots-will-need-to-be-taken-forever
https://828cloud.wordpress.com/2021/06/09/unthinkable-thoughts
From: Victoria Danberg
To: James Epstein
Sent: Thu, Sep 30, 2021
Subject: REDACTED Walk-In Booster COVID for 65 and Older
Dear Residents,
FYI: Please spread the word that REDACTED Pharmacy is offering walk-in (no appointment needed)COVID booster shots for anyone 65 years or older.
Pfizer is fully approved. Moderna and J & J are not yet approved by the CDC. I have heard that approval may be a few weeks away.
You may phone them if you wish at REDACTED I have heard great things back from people who have gone there..
Regards,
Vicki Danberg
--
Vicki Danberg, Newton City Councilor at Large, Ward 6
Mob. 508.641.4500
Tel. 617.969.1756
Email: vdanberg@gmail.com
_________________________
September 28, 2021
OPEN LETTER TO MEDICAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE
Newton Public Schools and Superintendent's Medical Advisory Committee Attn: Dr. Ashish Jha, Dean of the School of Public Health at Brown University, Professor of Health Services, Policy, and Practice
Dr. Jodi Larson, Internal Medicine, Chief Quality and Experience Officer, Newton-Wellesley Hospital, NPS parent
Dr. Sandra Nelson, Infectious Disease Specialist, Mass General Hospital
Dr. Brenda Anders Pring, Pediatrician, HHS Advisory Board, NPS parent
Dr. Eric Rubin, Adjunct Professor of Immunology and Infectious Diseases, Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public HealthDr. Karen Sadler, Pediatrician, NPS School PhysicianDr. Oneeka Williams, Urologic Surgeon, Assistant Clinical Professor of Urology at Tufts University School of Medicine
Dr. Dori Zaleznik, Infectious Disease Specialist, former Chief Administrative Officer, HHS Commissioner and School Committee member
Dear Doctors:
I hope you have had opportunity to review this inquiry and consult, as need be, with Mayor Fuller, School Committee Chair Goldman and School Superintendent Fleishman.
While awaiting your response, there have been important developments. An international alliance of currently over 4,600 (and counting) medical scientists and physicians has strongly condemned the current strategy to treat COVID, essentially maintaining that it constitutes a “crime against humanity” for preventing physicians from providing life-saving treatments for their patients and suppressing open scientific discussion. https://eraoflight.com/2021/09/28/4600-doctors-scientists-sign-declaration-accusing-covid-policy-makers-of-crimes-against-humanity
Their signed declaration states that “one size fits all” treatment recommendations have resulted in needless illness and death.
The Newton Mayor and Public School "Vaxx or Else" campaign is precisely what that is. The School Committee Chair states this is under your medical advice and authorization.
Thus far there is no indication that you have considered the widespread medical findings that the vaccinated are the current COVID spreaders and accelerators of new more serious variants, not the unvaccinated. (Citations in below thread.)
Or that the vaccinated are trading their overall natural COVID immunities for a variant-specific immunity blocking their natural immunity to other variants -- predicating a need for booster after booster. https://rumble.com/vlvhy5-best-explanation-ive-seen-about-why-the-covid-jabs-are-killer-shots.html
Or that serious protracted health risks of these 'vaccines' exceed COVID medical risk for the general population, and especially very greatly (in terms of numbers) for children whose COVID risk is less than miniscule. https://www.vaxtestimonies.org/en/https://www.thegatewaypundit.com/2021/09/breaking-project-veritas-johnson-johnson-children-dont-need-fcking-covid-vaccine-unknown-repercussions-video/(And see citations in below thread.)
Or that masks -- bacteria promoting, oxygen hampering and CO2 recirculating -- are useless if not harmful. Or that their disparate requirement is nonsensical if truly a medical necessity, rather than largely political statement or mark of psychological subservience.
Reportedly you are the Medical Advisory Committee relied on by the City. Thus, all residents are being compelled to follow your professional judgment. As you are licensed medical professionals rather than elected or City officials, it is imperative that politics be kept out of your judgment.
We appreciate that you have taken this important responsibility, but we need your medical report or opinion addressing the serious concerns both conveyed herein and expanded upon (with citation) back through the chain of correspondence below. And beyond that if you feel required, we, of course, would encourage independent medical/scientific research from the plethora of available sources, avoiding censoring platforms such as Google.
If you take substantive issue with anything stated, we request explanation with documentation where appropriate.
We understand that you may need to transmit this through the Mayor or School Committee, but hope you agree that this is of the upmost of importance and deserves immediate attention.
Sincerely,
Jim Epstein
cc: Newton Mayor, Health and Human Services Commissioner, City Council President, School Committee Chair, School Superintendent, School Health Services Director
bcc: Unlisted Members of City Government and the Public
_________________________
September 22, 2021
Honorable Ruthanne Fuller, Mayor, City of Newton
Newton City Hall 1000 Commonwealth Ave., Newton Centre, MA 02459
Dear Mayor Fuller:
As you are aware by copy, earlier today I emailed this COVID-19 thread to physician members of the Newton Public Schools/Superintendent's Medical Advisory Committee.
I have requested that the Advisory Committee review and address my substantive points below as expeditiously as possible. This is important to insure that the growing evidence reversing the premise for the existing COVID-19 vaccines vis-a-vis the Delta variant -- along with heretofore censured therapeutic information -- be provided to the public as quickly as possible. (Or that the member physicians report back with explanation if they dispute the validity or seriousness of these considerations.)
Any help that your office can provide to move this along will be more than greatly appreciated.
I do have one additional serious concern, however. I recognize that you are one of 17 greater Boston mayor and manager signatories to the Coronavirus Response Coalition under the authority of the Metropolitan Area Planning Council. In the hopes of getting this important information out to the greater Boston Metropolitan area, you can see from my email that I included both MAPC Executive Director Draisen and Director of Government Affairs Weyant.
Unfortunately they have blocked my communications. I have little doubt this was knowing. Yesterday I successfully emailed them on these matters.
As I said previously, I am not naive. I understand the immense political pressures. Please muster the courage to carry this information to the MAPC and the greater Boston Metropolitan area.
These matters should not have to be left to ordinary citizens like me.
Thank you.
Jim Epstein
cc: Newton Public Schools/Superintendent's Medical Advisory Committee Members
_________________________
September 22, 2021
Newton Public Schools and Superintendent's Medical Advisory Committee
Attn: Dr. Ashish Jha, Dean of the School of Public Health at Brown University, Professor of Health Services, Policy, and Practice
Dr. Sandra Nelson, Infectious Disease Specialist, Mass General HospitalDr. Eric Rubin, Adjunct Professor of Immunology and Infectious Diseases, Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health
Dr. Karen Sadler, Pediatrician, NPS School PhysicianDr. Dori Zaleznik, Infectious Disease Specialist, former Chief Administrative Officer, HHS Commissioner and School Committee member
Dear Doctors:
Yesterday I elected to include you as cc addressees of the below chain of email correspondence.
The only (sort of) substantive response I received, below, is from a non-medical professional. He/she merely cites (below) a CDC Report updated Sept. 20, 2021, "Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 Vaccine Overview and Safety (also known as COMIRNATY)". That report is on FDA's "non-emergency approved" Pfizer vaccine, COMIRNATY, submitted in conjunction with BioNTech which, as I discussed below in the thread, is not expected to be available for years. Moreover, the CDC Report neither address the Delta variant nor the critical newly emerging evidence reversing the premise for the existing COVID-19 Vaccines vis-a-vis the Delta variant.
Accordingly, I am addressing this specifically to physician members of the School Committee's and Superintendent's Medical Advisory Committee for whom I can locate an email address. School Committee Chair Goldman has refused to provide me contact information for members of the Medical Advisory Committee.
I would respectfully request that the physician members review and address my substantive points in the below thread as expeditiously as possible in order to insure that the latest vaccine and therapeutic information be provided to the public without any further unnecessary delay. Alternatively, if the physician members dispute the validity or seriousness of these considerations, I would ask for a full explanation.
Thank you.
James E. Epstein
cc:
Newton School Committee and ChairNewton Public Schools SuperintendentNewton MayorNewton City Council and PresidentNewton Health and Human Services Commission ChairNewton Public Schools Health Services Director Executive Director, Greater Boston Metropolitan Area Planning CouncilDirector of Government Affairs, Greater Boston Metropolitan Area Planning CouncilCoronavirus Response Coalition of Greater Boston, Mayor/City Manager Signatories
_________________________
From: REDACTED:
To: James Epstein
Sent: Wed, Sep 22, 2021
Subject: RE: Misleading the Public and Exploding COVID-19 Rates
Hah! I love your sources! A collection of nutty qanon [sic] insanity. Becker News? Hindustan Times? The Expose? Really is that the best you can do? You are embarrassing yourself. Watch out for the lizard people and don’t forget that Trump has your back and in fact remains the President! Wait for the REVEAL!!!! The fun never stops
If you want some real efficacy data related to the Pfizer vaccine based on clinical trials and studies please take a look here. No more bullshit!
https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/vaccines/different-vaccines/Pfizer-BioNTech.html
_________________________
September 21, 2021
DUPLICATE VIA CERTIFIED MAILRETURN RECEIPT REQUESTEDThe Honorable Ruth Goldman
Chair, Newton School CommitteeNewton Education Center100 Walnut St.Newtonville, MA 02460
DUPLICATE VIA CERTIFIED MAIL
RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED
The Honorable Ruthanne Fuller
Mayor, City of NewtonNewton City Hall1000 Commonwealth Ave.
Newton Centre, MA 02459
DUPLICATE VIA CERTIFIED MAIL
RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED
The Honorable Marc Draisen
Executive Director Greater Boston Metropolitan Area Planning Council60 Temple Pl.Boston, MA 02111
Dear Chair Goldman, Mayor Fuller and Director Draisen:
I feel compelled to expand these communications to the Metropolitan Area Planning Council because under MAPC authority, Newton Mayor Fuller (along with 16 other Greater Boston Mayors) executed and released on August 20, 2021, a Joint Statement, "Local Officials Addressing the COVID-19 Surge".
That Statement provides in pertinent part: "...we remain deeply concerned about the Delta variant and its potential public health impacts, especially among residents who are not yet vaccinated... We are committed to providing clear and consistent guidance for our our residents, GROUNDED IN THE MOST UP-TO-DATE DATA AND SCIENCE... we will continue to work with state and federal officials to adjust our guidance IN RESPONSE TO EMERGING SCIENTIFIC DATA..." [emphasis added]
I would ask each of you carefully to review the below chain of emails. Despite the immediacy of the growing health crisis as compounded by critical newly emerging evidence reversing the premise for the existing COVID-19 Vaccines vis-a-vis the Delta variant, the Mayor has elected not to respond. The City's Health Commission Chair has elected not to respond. The School System's Director of Health Services has elected not to respond. Moreover, NOT ONE of 24 elected Newton City Council members -- officially cc'd along the way -- have elected to respond. The only response even touching on substance from a Bcc recipient within the City, is included below indicative of the derision I have incurred for raising this matter.
Having said that, the School Committee Chair HAS replied (below), but elected to pass complete responsibility from the School Committee -- including from the Mayor as an ex officio member thereof -- to a "Medical Advisory Committee". An Advisory Committee which neither the School Committee nor Superintendent elected to consult after they were apprised of newly increasing disturbing news on the vaccine's safety and effectiveness and the dangers of censoring all therapeutic information.
Nor does the School Committee Chair apparently want me to consult with the Medical Advisory Committee. She refuses to provide contact information. Moreover, she reports that the Medical Advisory Committee has not come to the City or School System on any of this.
I am not naive. I am well aware of extreme political pressure felt not only by City elected officials and employees, but on the Medical Advisory Committee itself, to continuing a narrative. But as the premise for that narrative drastically changes due to newly emerging data and science, there is an obligation for the health, safety and well being of not only Newton residents, but residents of the Commonwealth, which must trump that political pressure.
At the very least, as I have repeatedly asked, please cause to be done whatever further investigation and research you deem necessary, and report fully and honestly to the people and take all appropriate steps to safeguard the public.
I have a feeling that when the full truth about this 'pandemic' emerges, you will be politically rewarded as well for your courage.
Thank you.
James E. Epstein
_________________________
From: James Epstein
To: REDACTED
Sent: Sep 21, 2021
Subject: Misleading the Public and Exploding COVID-19 Rates
September 21, 2021
REDACTED,
Please, if you have not already done so, at least read and watch the authorities which I previously linked in the below thread, confirming my points:
https://populist.press/testimony-pfizer-vaccine-is-useless-against-delta-variant/
https://theexpose.uk/2021/09/16/8-times-as-many-died-due-to-covid-vaccines-than-people-who-died-of-covid-19/
As well, please see these authorities and references submitted since then (just a few of many many):
https://populist.press/bombshell-federal-govt-whistleblower-goes-public-with-secret-covid-recordings/
https://theexpose.uk/2021/09/12/three-studies-find-the-covid-19-vaccines-do-not-work
https://iowaclimate.org/2021/09/16/uttar-pradesh-india-wipes-out-covid-with-ivermectin
Moreover, “Israeli doctor Kobi Haviv told Channel 13 News: “95% of seriously ill patients are vaccinated. Fully vaccinated people account for 85-90% of hospitalizations. We are opening more and more COVID branches. The effectiveness of vaccines is declining or disappearing.”
Finally, "Vermont, with the highest vaccination rate in the country -- 69% of adults fully vaccinated -- has set a new record high number of COVID cases. This comes just 3.5 months after Fauci said with 50% of adults vaccinated we wouldn’t see significant surges. This same pattern is happening all around the world in the most vaccinated countries."
At least you are the first to address substance.
Jim Epstein
_________________________
From: REDACTED
To: JAMES EPSTEIN
Sent: Sep 21, 2021
Subject: Misleading the Public and Exploding COVID-19 Rates
"Simply put, the more vaccines, the more Covid. Case rates are exploding in areas with high levels of vaccination."
Are you REDACTED out of your mind? What is wrong with you? Absolutely insane...
_________________________
September 20, 2021
Chair Goldman,
I am more than disappointed that apparently none of the members of the Superintendent's Medical Advisory Committee -- upon which you say you exclusively rely -- have even raised or discussed these critical health questions with you, the Mayor, the School Committee or NPS leadership. As well, I am surprised that the School Committee has elected not to go back to the Medical Advisory Committee in light of the disturbing ever increasing news on the vaccine's safety and effectiveness as well as censoring all therapeutic information.
This is most troubling.
As you can see below, I also have reached out to the City's Health Commission Chair and School System's Director of Health Services. I have yet to hear back from either of them.
Although you have linked for me the list of Medical Advisory Committee Members, below, obviously I will need their email contact information which you elected not to provide. I would more than appreciate that as quickly as possible.
Dr. Brenda Anders Pring, Pediatrician, HHS Advisory Board, NPS parent
Dr. Ashish Jha, Dean of the School of Public Health at Brown University, Professor of Health Services, Policy, and PracticeDr. Jodi Larson, Internal Medicine, Chief Quality and Experience Officer, Newton-Wellesley Hospital, NPS parentDr. Sandra Nelson, Infectious Disease Specialist, Mass General HospitalDr. Eric Rubin, Adjunct Professor of Immunology and Infectious Diseases, Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health
Dr. Karen Sadler, Pediatrician, NPS School PhysicianDr. Oneeka Williams, Urologic Surgeon, Assistant Clinical Professor of Urology at Tufts University School of MedicineDr. Dori Zaleznik, Infectious Disease Specialist, former Chief Administrative Officer, HHS Commissioner and School Committee member
Thank you.
Jim Epstein
_________________________
From: Ruth Goldman
To: James Epstein
Sent: Mon, Sep 20, 2021Subject:
Re: OPEN LETTER TO NEWTON SCHOOL COMMITTEE AND CHAIR RUTH GOLDMAN
Hi James:
As I have mentioned in previous emails, NPS and the Superintendent rely on a Medical Advisory Committee for recommendations and guidance around COVID policies and protocols. These individuals have been selected because of their experience and credentials in pediatrics, health and human services, infectious disease and epidemiology. They have advised us on the range of topics they deem most pertinent and relevant to the safe, in-person return to school for all NPS students and employees. Thus, our guidance on vaccination, masking, testing, ventilation, and distancing for meal times is all directly related to their recommendations on these critical strategies for reducing the risk of COVID in our schools.
The use of therapeutics has not arisen during our conversations. NPS leadership and SC are not in the position of making unilateral COVID recommendations without guidance and recommendations from these professionals as well as our own Newton Health and Human Services (3 of whom are ON the Medical Advisory)
Thank you for your email.
Best,
Ruth
September 20, 2021
Deborah Youngblood, Chair Newton Health and Human Services CommissionRuth Hoshino, RN
Director of Newton Public Schools Health Services
Dear Ms. Youngblood and Ms. Hoshino:
Please read the below two letters.
I write to you as professional administrators and practitioners. You are not elected officials. It's time to put politics aside. It's time to address the rapidly evolving facts and circumstances surrounding COVID-19 and current vaccines.
The Pfizer Vaccine is useless against the Delta variant, actually harmful. https://populist.press/testimony-pfizer-vaccine-is-useless-against-delta-variant
Simply put, the more vaccines, the more Covid. Case rates are exploding in areas with high levels of vaccination. https://beckernews.com/more-vaccines-more-covid-why-are-case-rates-exploding-in-areas-with-high-levels-of-vaccination-41523
Please do whatever further investigation and research you deem necessary concerning the dubious safety, efficacy, and wider impact of the 'vaccines'.
I ask that you advise me on how you will proceed on this. Alternatively, if you dispute the seriousness of these considerations, I would ask for a full explanation.
Sorry for any redundancy on these communications, but I am at a loss as to what else to do since it appears no one else will step forward.
Thank you.
Sincerely,
Jim Epstein
September 18, 2021
OPEN LETTER TO NEWTON SCHOOL COMMITTEE, CHAIR RUTH GOLDMAN, AND SCHOOL SUPERINTENDENT DAVID FLEISHMAN
Dear Chair Goldman and Superintendent Fleishman:
The Newton School Committee and Newton Public Schools have issued, or have had issued, report after report, study after study, and page after page of directive about COVID-19, vaccines, masks, ventilation, social distancing and curtailment of school programs and activities BUT NOT ONE WORD ABOUT THERAPEUTICS.
Please deem the below September 17, 2021 letter to Mayor Fuller to be fully incorporated herein as a protest to and request of the School Committee and Public Schools officially publicly to distribute information on COVID-19 Therapeutics, and to take up this matter as soon as possible and at the next School Committee Meeting.
Your continuing censuring of such information under the current circumstances of mandating and/or promoting masks and vaccines with now serious questions as to their efficacy and safety, to the exclusion of any information on therapeutics, is deemed a violation of your responsibilities concerning the health, safety and well being of Newton Public School employees and students and the public at large.
Please inform me of your actions taken in response hereto, or if you continue to dispute, your full explanation.
Sincerely,
Jim Epstein
September 17, 2021
DUPLICATE VIA CERTIFIED MAIL
RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED
Honorable Ruthanne Fuller
Mayor, City of NewtonNewton City Hall
1000 Commonwealth Ave, Newton Centre, MA 02459
Dear Mayor Fuller:
I note that to date, NOT ONE of your many many many COVID-19 Mayor's Updates has EVER mentioned the availability of proven known safe therapeutics, including Ivermectin, Hydroxychloroquine and Monoclonal Antibodies.
This, despite controversy surrounding the safety, unknowns, deceptive reporting and efficacy of the various vaccines which were approved only for emergency use in the absence of readily available therapeutic treatments. As I previously wrote you, the FDA's "non-emergency approved" Pfizer vaccine is not expected to be available for years. And regardless of questions on the vaccines, why would you withhold vital information on therapeutics if your concern over the health of Newton residents were paramount?
For your information, the largest state in India, Uttar Pradesh, recently promoted Ivermectin and Hydroxychloroquine to its massive population of an estimated 241 million people and "has now become free from COVID-19 government informed onFriday. The recovery rate has increased up to 98.7% proving the effectiveness of Ivermectin as part of the Uttar Pradesh Covid Control Model.” https://www.hindustantimes.com/cities/lucknow-news/33-districts-in-uttar-pradesh-are-now-covid-free-state-govt-101631267966925.html
Your singular promotion of vaccines persists despite the United States currently admitting and dispersing throughout the country this year alone over one million untested and unvaccinated illegal immigrants -- with a full scale invasion of ten thousand yesterday alone pouring in at ONE "borderless" crossing.
https://populist.press/shocking-video-10000-illegals-just-invaded-texas-town-overnight
https://cis.org/Bensman/New-Beachhead-Opens-Biden-Border-Crisis
This certainly belies any seriousness and credibility in claiming that vaccines, or even testing, are earnestly needed as an essential tool or mandate for handling COVID-19.
Moreover, last year's dramatic reduction of flu cases to practically zero indicates COVID-19 cases merely numerically replaced the flu. The current PCR testing is unable to distinguish COVID-19 from the flu, which precisely is the reason the CDC is withdrawing the use of such test after December 2021. (I guess until then the COVID-19 'cases' will remain high and then drastically reduce which can be 'claimed' due to the vaccines.)
And, as everyone now knows, COVID-19 deaths have been inflated by counting all those dying WITH COVID-19 as dying FROM COVID-19 irrespective of other serious medical condition(s) likely to have caused the fatality. Furthermore, there is now official data from the UK that 8 times as many people have died due to the Covid Vaccines in 6 months than people who have died of COVID-19 in 18 months.
https://theexpose.uk/2021/09/16/8-times-as-many-died-due-to-covid-vaccines-than-people-who-died-of-covid-19/
In any event, I urge that your very next COVID-19 Mayor's Update fully inform on the availability of therapeutics. Also, I feel it is incumbent upon you to present the differing reports and opinions on the safety and efficacy of the vaccines to enable informed consent as to their use. Even the CDC just this month quietly downgraded the definition of "vaccine" from "produce immunity to a specific disease" to "produce protection from a specific disease". Beyond that, many maintain an experimental mRNA agent is not even a "vaccine".
You have a duty to do more than just cite CDC or NIH and be done with it. Their ever evolving statements and findings may or not be accurate. This is especially the case since there are reports that NIH's Dr. Fauci faces criminal indictment for falsifications and blocking therapeutic information, to occur once the stolen November 3 Presidential election is rectified.
Sincerely,
Jim Epstein
cc:
Newton City Council, Attn: Susan Albright, President, Newton School Committee, Attn: Ruth Goldman, Chair, Newton Health and Human Services Department, Attn: Deborah Youngblood, Commissioner